As “Virgin River” showrunner Patrick Smith teases plans for a prequel, fans are debating which storylines would make for an engaging new series—and which ones should be avoided. Here are five potential prequel ideas that have excited fans, as well as three that might not work.
5 Stories Fans Want to See
Doc Mullins’ Early Career – Many fans would love to see a young Doc arriving in Virgin River, navigating small-town medicine, and developing the gruff yet kindhearted personality viewers adore today.
Hope McCrea’s Rise to Mayor – Hope is one of the most dynamic characters on the show. A prequel exploring her younger years, including her first encounters with Doc, could add depth to her character.
Mel’s Parents’ Love Story – With so much of Mel’s life revolving around her mother’s past, a prequel exploring her parents’ love story could offer a touching perspective.
Jack’s Military Days – While technically not a prequel set in Virgin River, a series showcasing Jack’s time as a Marine, his bond with his unit, and the events leading to his PTSD could provide gripping drama.
The Founding of Virgin River – Taking a completely different approach, the prequel could explore the town’s origins, focusing on its earliest residents and the struggles they faced.
3 Stories Fans Don’t Want
Random New Characters Unconnected to the Main Show – If the prequel introduces an entirely new cast with no ties to the “Virgin River” world, it could struggle to maintain fan interest.
Rewriting Established Canon – A prequel that contradicts details from the main show would likely frustrate fans and cause more harm than good.
A Love Story with No Stakes – “Virgin River” thrives on high-stakes romance. If the prequel features a love story with no compelling conflict, it might not hold viewers’ attention.
With fan opinions varying widely, the showrunners have an opportunity to craft a prequel that both honors the existing show and brings something fresh to the table. Whether they succeed depends on the choices they make—and how willing fans are to embrace the past.
