Chicago P.D. has never shied away from putting its characters through emotional and professional turmoil, but Season 12, Episode 13 proves once again that Kevin Atwater just can’t catch a break. Over the years, LaRoyce Hawkins’ character has been a fan favorite, a rare mix of integrity, street smarts, and leadership potential. Yet, every time Atwater seems to be on the verge of real character growth or a major breakthrough, the show pulls him back into the same tragic cycle. And this episode is no different.
Atwater’s Never-Ending Struggles
From the moment the episode begins, it’s clear that Atwater is once again at the center of a high-stakes case—one that forces him to confront his past, his morals, and the systemic challenges that continue to shape his world. While Chicago P.D. often gives him compelling storylines, the problem is that they always seem to follow the same pattern: Atwater fights for justice, faces personal and professional consequences, and ends up in the same position as before, without any real progress.
This time, he’s thrown into a case that should have allowed him to shine. Instead, the episode leans into familiar territory—forcing Atwater into yet another impossible situation where he has to choose between doing what’s right and protecting himself. It’s a frustratingly familiar arc that feels like déjà vu for longtime fans.
A Pattern That Needs to Break
Atwater has repeatedly proven he’s one of the most morally grounded characters in Intelligence. He’s risked his career, his safety, and his relationships to stand up for what he believes in. Yet, instead of allowing him to rise through the ranks or evolve in meaningful ways, Chicago P.D. keeps him stuck in a cycle of suffering. While other characters like Ruzek, Burgess, and even Upton have had arcs that allowed them to move forward, Atwater seems destined to relive the same battles over and over again. The show has an opportunity to explore new layers of his character—whether through a leadership role, a stable personal life, or a case that finally rewards his loyalty and dedication. But instead, Episode 13 feels like yet another reminder that Chicago P.D. isn’t ready to let Atwater win.
What’s Next for Atwater?
With only a few episodes left in the season, fans can only hope that Chicago P.D. finally gives Atwater a storyline that doesn’t just highlight his struggles, but actually pushes him forward. Whether that means a well-earned promotion, a romantic subplot that isn’t doomed from the start, or a case that solidifies his standing as a leader in Intelligence, it’s time for the show to break the cycle.
