Yellowstone has been a TV phenomenon since its debut, captivating audiences with its gripping drama, breathtaking scenery, and powerhouse performances. But as the show heads toward its final season, fans have started noticing a troubling trend—some of its lowest-rated episodes have something in common: Kevin Costner is barely in them or missing entirely.
So, what does this mean for Taylor Sheridan’s hit series? Let’s dive deep into Yellowstone’s weakest episodes and uncover the harsh reality about the show’s struggles without its leading man.
The Heart of Yellowstone: Kevin Costner’s Role as John Dutton
Why Kevin Costner’s John Dutton Is Irreplaceable
From the very first episode, Kevin Costner has embodied John Dutton—the rugged, no-nonsense patriarch of the Dutton family and owner of the largest ranch in Montana. His presence commands every scene, and his character’s moral complexity keeps viewers engaged.
Without him, Yellowstone loses more than just a central character—it loses its anchor.
The Power of Costner’s Performance
Costner’s acting brings depth to John Dutton. He’s not just a cowboy fighting for his land; he’s a leader, a strategist, and a father facing impossible choices. His absence creates a void that even Yellowstone’s strong supporting cast struggles to fill.
The Lowest-Rated Yellowstone Episodes: A Pattern Emerges
The Episodes That Fans Disliked Most
IMDb ratings don’t lie. The lowest-rated episodes in Yellowstone’s history tend to be the ones where Kevin Costner is either missing or sidelined. Here are a few examples:
- Season 5, Episode 7 (“The Dream Is Not Me”) – Lacked John Dutton’s commanding presence, focusing instead on side characters.
- Season 4, Episode 5 (“Under a Blanket of Red”) – A slow-moving episode that fans felt dragged on without enough John Dutton screen time.
- Season 3, Episode 3 (“An Acceptable Surrender”) – Shifted focus away from the main conflict, leaving viewers disengaged.
What Made These Episodes Underwhelming?
These episodes lacked the tension, drama, and leadership that John Dutton brings to the show. Without him, storylines felt less urgent, and side plots didn’t hold the same weight.
The Harsh Reality: Yellowstone Isn’t the Same Without Costner
The Show Struggles to Maintain Its Identity
Taylor Sheridan’s writing is known for its gritty realism and high-stakes drama, but Yellowstone’s identity is deeply tied to John Dutton. When the show shifts focus away from him, it loses the spark that made it a hit in the first place.
Can the Supporting Cast Carry the Show?
Yellowstone has an incredible ensemble, including Kelly Reilly (Beth Dutton), Luke Grimes (Kayce Dutton), and Cole Hauser (Rip Wheeler). But no matter how talented they are, there’s a noticeable difference when Costner is absent.
Beth’s fiery personality, Kayce’s internal struggles, and Rip’s loyalty all shine brighter when they’re interacting with John Dutton. Without him, they feel disconnected from the show’s core purpose.
The Bigger Issue: Taylor Sheridan’s Expanding Universe
Too Many Spin-Offs, Not Enough Focus?
Taylor Sheridan is a storytelling genius, but with projects like 1883, 1923, Mayor of Kingstown, and Tulsa King, it’s clear he’s spread thin. Could this be impacting Yellowstone’s quality?
The Future of Yellowstone Without Costner
With rumors of Costner’s exit, fans are worried about what comes next. Can Yellowstone survive without John Dutton?
Can Yellowstone Bounce Back?
Possible Ways to Save the Show
If Yellowstone wants to avoid a disappointing ending, it needs to:
- Refocus on John Dutton – Even if Costner’s screen time is limited, his presence should drive the story.
- Strengthen Side Storylines – Develop compelling arcs for Beth, Kayce, and Rip that don’t feel like filler.
- Deliver High-Stakes Conflict – Bring back the tension and drama that made the show great.
What Fans Want from the Final Season
Yellowstone fans are vocal about their desires: they want a satisfying conclusion, not a watered-down version of their favorite show.
Final Thoughts: Will Yellowstone’s Legacy Be Tainted?
Yellowstone has built a loyal fanbase and redefined modern Western dramas. But as the lowest-rated episodes prove, the show struggles when Kevin Costner isn’t front and center. If Taylor Sheridan wants to cement Yellowstone’s place in TV history, he needs to ensure John Dutton’s legacy remains intact.
Will the final season deliver? Fans can only hope.
