Steel Magnolias (1989) remains a classic film, remembered for its unforgettable characters, powerful performances, and emotional storylines. The film’s ensemble cast—featuring Julia Roberts, Sally Field, Dolly Parton, Shirley MacLaine, Olympia Dukakis, and Daryl Hannah—has become iconic over the years. However, there are several behind-the-scenes secrets about how the film came together, including a stunning revelation from Julia Roberts herself.
In a recent interview, Roberts shared that Steel Magnolias almost looked very different, particularly in the role that would launch her into stardom. According to Roberts, actress Meg Ryan was initially considered for the role of Shelby Eatenton Latcherie, the beloved character she ultimately portrayed. This casting twist is just one of many interesting facts about how the film’s cast was assembled, and it sheds new light on how Steel Magnolias almost didn’t feature one of Hollywood’s most famous actresses.
In this article, we’ll explore these surprising casting stories, including how Roberts landed the role, what might have been if Meg Ryan played Shelby, and some other fascinating behind-the-scenes details that you may not have known.
Julia Roberts and the Role of Shelby Eatenton Latcherie
How Julia Roberts Got the Role of Shelby
Julia Roberts was a relative newcomer when she was cast as Shelby in Steel Magnolias. At the time, she had appeared in a few films, but Steel Magnolias was her breakthrough role. According to Roberts, it was her first big opportunity to truly showcase her acting range, and she had to work hard to secure the part.
When she first read for the role, Roberts didn’t immediately believe she would get the part. The role of Shelby was pivotal to the story—Shelby’s struggle with diabetes and her strained relationship with her mother, M’Lynn (played by Sally Field), are at the heart of the film’s emotional power. Roberts’s ability to capture Shelby’s youthful spirit, vulnerability, and strength made her the perfect fit. Despite not being a household name at the time, Roberts convinced the filmmakers that she was right for the role, ultimately landing the part that would change her life.
Meg Ryan Almost Played Shelby: What Might Have Been?
Meg Ryan’s Close Call
One of the most surprising pieces of Steel Magnolias trivia is the fact that Meg Ryan was considered for the role of Shelby before Julia Roberts. According to Roberts herself, she was aware of the fact that Ryan was the first choice for the role. Ryan was already an established actress with a rising career, having appeared in films like When Harry Met Sally (1989) and The Doors (1991).
Roberts admits that Meg Ryan’s popularity at the time could have made her a perfect fit for Shelby, especially given the character’s charming and sweet disposition. However, according to Roberts, the chemistry between herself and Sally Field was what really made her the right choice for the role.
“I don’t know if Meg was ever really interested in it, but she was definitely someone they had in mind,” Roberts said in her interview. “It’s wild to think that she could have been in that role instead of me, but I’m glad it worked out the way it did.”
The Impact of Julia Roberts’ Casting on Her Career
How Steel Magnolias Launched Julia Roberts’ Career
The casting of Julia Roberts as Shelby Eatenton Latcherie marked a pivotal moment in her career. Steel Magnolias was released in 1989, and although Roberts was already in the industry, it was her standout performance in the film that catapulted her into the public eye. Her portrayal of Shelby, with her heartbreaking vulnerability and radiant personality, earned her widespread critical acclaim, and soon, Hollywood was taking notice.
Within the next few years, Roberts became one of the most bankable stars in Hollywood, thanks in no small part to her role in Steel Magnolias. The following year, she starred in Pretty Woman (1990), which cemented her place as a major Hollywood A-lister. Her career would go on to include iconic roles in films like My Best Friend’s Wedding (1997), Erin Brockovich (2000), and Ocean’s Eleven (2001).
Sally Field and the Bond Between M’Lynn and Shelby
The Mother-Daughter Dynamic That Shaped the Film
While Julia Roberts’s breakthrough performance as Shelby was a key part of the film’s success, it was her dynamic with Sally Field, who played her mother M’Lynn, that really anchored Steel Magnolias. The relationship between Shelby and M’Lynn is emotional, intense, and ultimately one of the most moving parts of the film. The bond between the two characters became a central element of the story, and their performances together were praised by critics.
Sally Field, a veteran actress, was supportive of Roberts throughout the filming process. Field’s own experience and empathy allowed her to mentor Roberts, especially considering the emotional intensity of their scenes together. According to Roberts, Field was “a rock” for her during the production, and their relationship on screen mirrored their real-life connection.
“I really feel like we grew up together on that set,” Roberts recalled. “Sally was like a second mother to me. We had so many long, quiet talks between takes. It was a safe space to explore the role.”
Other Surprising Casting Details
Dolly Parton’s Perfect Fit as Truvy
While the role of Shelby almost went to someone else, the casting of Dolly Parton as Truvy, the vivacious beauty salon owner, was spot-on from the start. Parton, already a massive country music icon, took on the role of Truvy with ease, blending her natural charm and wit with the character’s larger-than-life persona.
Parton’s presence in Steel Magnolias added a special touch to the film, with her balance of humor and heart. Parton later shared that she felt an immediate connection to the role, saying, “I loved the character from the very first time I read the script. She reminded me of the kind of women I grew up with—strong, loving, and full of life.”
Shirley MacLaine and Olympia Dukakis: The Perfect Southern Sass
Another interesting tidbit about the casting process is how Shirley MacLaine and Olympia Dukakis were cast as Ouiser Boudreaux and Clairee Belcher, respectively. Both actresses brought their own unique brand of sass and humor to their characters, and their chemistry with the rest of the cast was undeniable.
Shirley MacLaine’s sharp wit as Ouiser and Olympia Dukakis’s regal yet humorous portrayal of Clairee became two of the film’s most beloved characters. The two actresses created a memorable dynamic that added depth to the story, and both received rave reviews for their performances.
The Enduring Legacy of Steel Magnolias
Why Steel Magnolias Continues to Touch Hearts
Despite the behind-the-scenes drama, Steel Magnolias remains one of the most beloved films of its era, with its themes of friendship, strength, and resilience continuing to resonate with audiences. The casting choices were key to the film’s lasting impact, with each actress bringing something unique to her role. While Julia Roberts’ casting was arguably the most pivotal, the film’s ensemble cast created a perfect balance of humor and heartache that made the story timeless.
Even decades after its release, Steel Magnolias remains a go-to film for anyone looking for a heartwarming and emotional experience. The film’s legacy lives on, and its cast continues to be celebrated for their performances, many of which would go on to define their careers.
Conclusion: What Could Have Been vs. What Was
Julia Roberts’ role in Steel Magnolias was more than just a career-defining moment—it was a chance for the young actress to shine in a story filled with heart and soul. The fact that Meg Ryan was considered for the role adds an intriguing “what might have been” twist to the story, but it’s clear that Roberts was the perfect fit for Shelby. Her chemistry with Sally Field, Dolly Parton, and the rest of the cast created a memorable experience for audiences.
Looking back at the casting secrets, we can appreciate how close the film came to being a very different experience. However, the iconic ensemble we ended up with became a part of film history, and Steel Magnolias remains a testament to the incredible talent that brought the story to life.
FAQs
1. Was Meg Ryan originally cast as Shelby in Steel Magnolias?
No, Meg Ryan was considered for the role of Shelby, but Julia Roberts ultimately landed the part, which became a breakout role for her career.
2. How did Sally Field help Julia Roberts on set?
Sally Field acted as a mentor to Julia Roberts, offering emotional support and guidance, which helped Roberts navigate the emotional complexity of her role.
