The upcoming Blue Bloods spinoff, Boston Blue, has cast its latest star. After a run that spanned more than a decade, Blue Bloods ended its run on CBS after 14 seasons. News followed in February that a spinoff of the police procedural was moving forward at the network, with Donnie Wahlberg reprising the role of Danny Reagan, though he’ll be joined by a largely new cast.
Deadline has confirmed the latest addition to the upcoming spinoff, confirming that Psych’s Maggie Lawson is set to join Boston Blue in a main cast member capacity alongside Wahlberg and the previously announced actors Sonequa Martin-Green and Ernie Hudson. Lawson, known for her role as Juliet O’Hara in the long-running crime dramedy Psych, will play the Superintendent of the Boston Police Department.
What The Latest Cast Addition Means For Boston Blue
It’s A Family Affair
Reprising his role as NYPD Officer Danny Reagan, Wahlberg’s character takes a job with the Boston Police Department. He gets paired with Detective Lena Silver (Martin-Green), the eldest daughter of a prominent law enforcement family, and he’ll work under Sarah Silver (Lawson), the Superintendent of the Boston Police Department, who is described as confident. She is also Lena’s stepsister, walking the tightrope between her family and her job.
The family ties are completed by Ernie Hudson’s character, who plays Reverend Peters. The patriarch of the blended Silver family, Peters is the father of Mae Silver, Boston’s District Attorney, and grandfather of Detective Lena Silver, Sarah Silver (Lawson), and rookie patrol cop Isaac Silver. Some of these roles have yet to be announced, but it sets up the spinoff to have a different family focus than the original series.
Our Take On How Boston Blue Is Shaping Up
It Has The Right Stuff
The spinoff, which is produced by CBS Studios in association with Jerry Bruckheimer TV, with Brandon Sonnier and Brandon Margolis as showrunners and executive producers, will be a departure from the long-running police procedural. However, with Jerry Bruckheimer, KristieAnne Reed, and Wahlberg himself as executive producers, plus the veteran Anthony Hemingway as director, there will be a lot of progression. There is also continuity in terms of the story, although the family of Boston Blue has their own challenges and struggles that will set the new drama apart from what came before with the Reagan family.
Enjoy ScreenRant’s primetime coverage? Click below to sign up for my weekly Network TV newsletter (make sure to check “Network TV” in your preferences) and get the inside scoop from actors and showrunners on your favorite series.
Hold onto your badge—because things are about to get very interesting in the Blue Bloods universe.
CBS has officially announced that a fan-favorite actor from USA Network’s hit show Psych is joining the cast of the upcoming Blue Bloods spinoff. Known for his quirky charm and brilliant crime-solving skills, this new addition is set to bring both wit and warmth to the tough world of law enforcement.
Let’s break down who’s been cast, what their role will be, and why this unexpected crossover is exactly what the Blue Bloods spinoff needs to hit the ground running.
A Spinoff With Serious Buzz
The Expansion of the Blue Bloods Universe
Blue Bloods has been a CBS staple for over a decade, blending gritty cop drama with heartfelt family moments. Now, with the spinoff in development, the network is ready to pass the torch—while keeping the same values: justice, loyalty, and legacy.
Why Fans Are Eager for the Spinoff
After 14 strong seasons, fans are hungry for more. The spinoff promises a fresh setting, a new team, and deeper dives into modern policing—without losing the soul of the original.
So, Who’s Joining the Force?
Dulé Hill Steps Into the Badge
That’s right—Dulé Hill, best known as Burton “Gus” Guster from Psych, has been officially cast as a senior officer in the new Blue Bloods spinoff. Known for his quick wit and sharp timing, Hill is a welcome surprise to fans who love character-driven dramas.
A Shift From Comedy to Cop Drama
You might be thinking—Wait, the guy from Psych? Yes, but don’t let his sitcom background fool you. Dulé has serious range, and his dramatic performances (remember The West Wing?) prove he’s more than ready to take on a uniformed role.
Meet Officer Miles Bennett—Hill’s New Character
Veteran Cop With a Complicated Past
Dulé Hill will portray Officer Miles Bennett, a seasoned beat cop with nearly 20 years on the job. Street-smart and respected, Miles is known for his deep connections in the community—and his habit of challenging orders when he feels they cross a moral line.
A Key Player in the New Reagan-Adjacent Squad
Miles isn’t just another uniform. He’s one of the main characters anchoring the new precinct the spinoff revolves around. Expect him to serve as both a mentor and a wildcard in the squad.
The Boston Connection—Where the Spinoff Takes Place
From New York to Boston: A Tale of Two Cities
The spinoff shifts from NYC to Boston, offering a new lens on crime and community. The Boston PD has a different culture, different challenges, and different methods—and this setting opens the door for rich, regionally grounded storytelling.
Officer Bennett’s Backstory Is Boston Born and Bred
Miles Bennett is a Roxbury native, born to a schoolteacher and a former Marine. His character arc explores the tension between community loyalty and law enforcement duty—a balancing act that echoes today’s headlines.
The New Cast Is Packed With Talent
Not Just Dulé—An All-Star Ensemble
Hill joins a growing cast that includes:
-
Liev Schreiber as Police Commissioner Tommy Reagan
-
Ana de la Reguera as Detective Elena Reagan
-
Jurnee Smollett as journalist-turned-family-matriarch Claudia Reagan
-
Daniel Diemer as Assistant D.A. Sean Reagan
Building Chemistry From Day One
Insiders report that Dulé clicked with the cast immediately during table reads. His natural charisma and grounded delivery are already setting a new tone for the show.
Why Dulé Hill Is a Perfect Fit for the Role
Blending Brains, Humor, and Heart
Hill has the unique ability to blend intelligence with vulnerability. He can deliver a powerful speech on systemic justice one moment—and crack a dry joke the next. That balance fits right in with Blue Bloods’ DNA.
A Familiar Face, A New Flavor
Bringing in someone familiar from a beloved show like Psych bridges fan bases, while also giving the spinoff its own identity. This isn’t just a casting stunt—it’s a smart play.
What We Know About the Spinoff So Far
Working Title: Boston Blue
CBS hasn’t confirmed a title, but Boston Blue has been floated during production leaks. The focus will be on another branch of the Reagan family in Boston, dealing with their own unique challenges.
Grittier, More Grounded Stories
Expect less polished NYPD protocol and more gritty, boots-on-the-ground action. The show promises to tackle real-world issues like community policing, political interference, and the mental health toll of the job.
When Will the Spinoff Air?
Expected Release: Fall 2025
Filming begins in late summer 2025, with a fall premiere slot expected. CBS has teased an extended trailer drop by early September.
Midseason Teasers Coming Soon
We should start seeing behind-the-scenes content, trailers, and cast interviews within the next few months to build the hype.
Fan Reactions Have Been Wildly Positive
Twitter Can’t Get Enough
As soon as CBS dropped the casting news, Blue Bloods and Psych fans took to social media. Memes, reaction videos, and fan theories exploded overnight.
Fan Quote of the Week
One tweet summed it up best: “Gus from Psych in Blue Bloods? My TV just grew a mustache and filed a police report.”
Will There Be Crossovers With the Original Blue Bloods?
Yes, But Sparingly
Producers say that while the two shows will exist in the same universe, crossover episodes will be “event-based” and kept rare to preserve each show’s identity.
The Reagan Legacy Lives On
That said, expect some phone calls, mentions, and maybe even an appearance from an OG Reagan or two.
What This Means for the Future of the Franchise
A Smart Move Toward Longevity
By blending legacy casting with fresh faces, CBS is setting up the Blue Bloods universe to last another decade. It’s Law & Order meets Succession, with a heartbeat.
A Balanced Blend of Old School and New Energy
Hill’s casting proves the network wants smart, dynamic actors who can carry serious storylines while keeping audiences emotionally invested.
Conclusion
The Blue Bloods spinoff just made its boldest move yet—and it’s already paying off. Casting Dulé Hill brings not only a familiar face but a whole new energy to a franchise known for its tradition. He’s stepping into a world of crime, honor, and moral complexity—but with the same charisma that made Psych fans fall in love.
If this is the direction the show is going, we’re all in. Expect Boston Blue (or whatever the final title becomes) to blend the best of old and new—classic family drama, high-stakes policing, and characters you can’t stop rooting for.
