Carrie Preston Opens Up About Elsbeth Season 2: Lessons Learned, Joys & Challenges Revealed

Television’s favorite quirky detective is back — and so is the actress who brings her to life with unapologetic charm. Carrie Preston, known for her delightfully eccentric role as Elsbeth Tascioni, is opening up about Season 2 of Elsbeth. From the joy of deepening her character to the pressures of leading a spinoff, Preston gives fans a front-row seat into her ever-evolving journey.

Let’s dive into the world of Elsbeth, the unexpected lessons, backstage stories, and what it really takes to play such a magnetic character.

“I Know What You Did Thirty-Three Summers Ago” – As Judge Milton Crawford (Michael Emerson) inches closer to becoming a federal judge, Elsbeth searches his past to prove he’s a murderer before it’s too late, but Elsbeth’s attempts to take Crawford down puts everyone around her in jeopardy. Meanwhile, Teddy considers following in his mother’s professional footsteps, on the CBS original series ELSBETH, Thursday, April 24 (9:00-10:00 PM, ET/PT) on the CBS Television Network, and streaming on Paramount+ (live and on demand for Paramount+ with SHOWTIME subscribers, or on demand for Paramount+ Essential subscribers the day after the episode airs)* Pictured (L-R): Michael Emerson as Judge Milton Crawford and Carrie Preston as Elsbeth Tascioni Photo: Michael Parmelee/CBS ©2025 CBS Broadcasting, Inc. All Rights Reserved.

🧠  Who Is Elsbeth Tascioni? A Quick Refresher

Before we break down the juicy details of Season 2, let’s take a quick walk down memory lane.

A Character Born in The Good Wife

Elsbeth Tascioni first popped up in The Good Wife, and instantly stole every scene she was in. Eccentric, brilliant, unpredictable — Elsbeth was a character like no other.

Why Elsbeth Resonates With Fans

Her unapologetically oddball persona feels real, fresh, and free from TV tropes. She’s not trying to be the smartest or the coolest — she just is.

🎬  Elsbeth Gets Her Own Show – And It’s a Hit

From Scene-Stealer to Leading Lady

When CBS greenlit Elsbeth, many wondered: could a side character carry her own series? Fast forward to Season 2, and the answer is a resounding “Yes!”

Preston’s Honest Take on Stepping Into the Spotlight

In her words, “It’s both exhilarating and terrifying.” Taking on the central role came with pressure — but also endless creative joy.

🌈 The Joys of Filming Elsbeth Season 2

 Exploring New Layers of Elsbeth’s Personality

Carrie shared that Season 2 peels back some layers. “We get to see why she ticks the way she does,” she reveals.

Chemistry With Guest Stars & Core Cast

Preston gushed about the ensemble, saying the rotating guest stars keep the show fresh. “It’s like having a new playground every week.”

New York City as a Living, Breathing Character

Much of Elsbeth Season 2 is filmed in NYC — a decision that brings a gritty, vibrant authenticity to each scene.

💥  The Challenges That Came With Season 2

 Balancing Humor and Drama

Preston admits the tone is tricky. “Elsbeth is funny, yes — but we can’t lose the stakes.”

The Weight of Expectations

After a successful first season, the pressure is on. Fans want more — and better. “It’s flattering, but it’s a lot,” Preston admits.

Navigating Creative Burnout

“Finance Bros” – When a Wall Street titan (Alan Ruck) is murdered after giving away his fortune, Elsbeth suspects the victim’s twin brother and business partner (also Alan Ruck) in a deadly case of sibling rivalry, on the CBS original series ELSBETH, Thursday, Feb. 6 (10:00-11:00 PM, ET/PT) on the CBS Television Network, and streaming on Paramount+ (live and on demand for Paramount+ with SHOWTIME subscribers, or on demand for Paramount+ Essential subscribers the day after the episode airs)* Pictured: Carrie Preston as Elsbeth Tascioni Photo: Michael Parmelee/CBS ©2024 CBS Broadcasting, Inc. All Rights Reserved.

With back-to-back filming and media duties, Carrie has learned the hard way to rest. “I’m learning how to protect my energy,” she said.

📚  What Carrie Preston Is Learning Through Elsbeth

The Power of Vulnerability

Elsbeth’s oddity is often misunderstood, but it also reflects deep vulnerability — something Preston is tapping into more this season.

 Embracing Imperfection On-Screen

“I don’t need to be polished. I need to be real,” Preston said. That realization has changed how she approaches not just acting, but life.

🧩 Behind-The-Scenes Insights You Haven’t Heard Before

Scripts Are Written With Carrie’s Voice in Mind

Writers now tailor lines to Carrie’s rhythm. “They know how I speak Elsbeth now,” she laughs.

Improvised Moments That Made It On-Screen

Preston reveals that some of Elsbeth’s best moments were not scripted. “Sometimes I just… go with it,” she says.

🎥  Carrie Preston’s Relationship With the Elsbeth Fanbase

Social Media Love and Fan Art Galore

From memes to watercolor portraits, fans are obsessed. “It’s incredibly moving,” Carrie said.

What Preston Wants Fans to Know

“If you see yourself in Elsbeth, embrace it. She’s proof that being different is powerful.”

“Unalive and Well” – When a young man is found dead in his car, Elsbeth visits the holistic wellness center he’d just left, and begins to suspect its charismatic founder (Eric McCormack), on the CBS original series ELSBETH, Thursday, Jan. 30 (10:00-11:00 PM, ET/PT) on the CBS Television Network, and streaming on Paramount+ (live and on demand for Paramount+ with SHOWTIME subscribers, or on demand for Paramount+ Essential subscribers the day after the episode airs)* Pictured: Carra Patterson as Kaya Blanke, Carrie Preston as Elsbeth Tascioni, and Danny Mastrogiorgio as Detective Smullen Photo: Michael Parmelee/CBS ©2024 CBS Broadcasting, Inc. All Rights Reserved.

🏆 Critical Praise and What It Means To Carrie

Emmy Buzz and Industry Recognition

There’s buzz around a potential Emmy nod for Preston — and it’s not without merit. “It’d be nice, but honestly, the fan response is the real reward.”

Why Critics Call Her Performance ‘Electric’

It’s hard to define — but Carrie’s energy as Elsbeth feels like lightning in a bottle. Every glance, every pause, every stumble has meaning.

🔮 What’s Next for Elsbeth Season 2?

Teasers Without Spoilers

Expect new cases, deeper emotional beats, and a mystery that ties the whole season together.

 Hints at a Possible Season 3

Carrie teased that writers are already brainstorming more storylines. “There’s so much more to explore,” she says with a knowing smile.

❤️ The Human Behind the Quirks

Carrie Preston Off-Screen

When she’s not Elsbeth, Carrie is a lover of theater, dogs, and long walks in Central Park. She’s grounded, gracious, and refreshingly down-to-earth.

Why Elsbeth Feels Personal To Her

Carrie said, “Elsbeth lets me embrace all the oddities I’ve hidden. She’s made me braver.”

📝 Conclusion: Elsbeth Is More Than a Show — It’s a Statement

Carrie Preston’s portrayal of Elsbeth is more than just good acting — it’s a celebration of uniqueness, emotional depth, and unfiltered brilliance. Season 2 isn’t just another chapter in the show — it’s a chapter in Carrie’s personal evolution. With her openness, humor, and honesty, Preston proves that the best characters are mirrors — reflecting something real back at us.

Whether you’re tuning in for the laughs, the twists, or just to see what Elsbeth wears next, one thing’s clear: there’s never been a character — or actress — quite like this.

Rate this post