The quirky legal dramedy So Help Me Todd quickly found a place in the hearts of fans with its unique mix of courtroom chaos and family drama. After a successful first season, fans have been buzzing about what’s coming next. The burning question? Who’s returning for Season 2?
Good news: 11 beloved cast members are officially expected to return, and that means more antics, clever twists, and emotional depth. Let’s break down who’s coming back, what that means for the show’s future, and why Season 2 might just be better than ever.
The Heart of the Show: What Made Season 1 Work
Before we dive into the returning cast, let’s talk about why this show stood out in the first place.
“So Help Me Todd” isn’t just another courtroom drama. It’s a show that blends mystery, comedy, and genuine emotion. The relationship between Margaret (a no-nonsense lawyer) and her son Todd (a private investigator with a knack for chaos) is what fuels the show’s charm.
Their dynamic is unpredictable, lovable, and—let’s be honest—super relatable if you’ve ever worked with family.
Confirmed & Expected to Return: The Core 11 Cast Members
Let’s get to the part you’re really here for: Who’s back for Season 2?
1. Marcia Gay Harden as Margaret Wright
There’s no “So Help Me Todd” without Margaret. Her commanding courtroom presence, sharp wit, and complicated bond with Todd are the backbone of the series. Marcia Gay Harden brings gravitas and warmth in equal measure—and yes, she’s back!
2. Skylar Astin as Todd Wright
The misfit private eye we all root for. Skylar Astin’s portrayal of Todd gives the show its humor and unpredictability. Whether he’s breaking into a suspect’s house or clashing with his mom, Todd’s return is non-negotiable—and confirmed.
3. Madeline Wise as Allison
Todd’s older sister and accomplished doctor, Allison adds a grounded, emotionally charged layer to the show. With her marriage issues and family drama still unresolved, expect her return to shake things up.
4. Tristen J. Winger as Lyle
Lyle, the always-suspicious and hilariously skeptical investigator, became a low-key fan favorite. His interactions with Todd are pure gold, and yes—he’s coming back for more deadpan brilliance.
5. Inga Schlingmann as Susan
Susan and Todd’s history adds a subtle romantic tension to the series. A returning Susan could mean a potential rekindling… or more complicated messes. Either way, she’s in.
6. Rosa Arredondo as Francey
Francey’s no-nonsense office manager vibe is both comforting and intimidating. We need her for Season 2 office chaos and reality checks, and it looks like we’re getting exactly that.
7. Thomas Cadrot as Chet Venables
Chet might not be in every episode, but his presence always adds layers. With his relationship with Allison under the microscope, his return means drama is on the horizon.
8. Leslie Silva as Beverly Crest
As a powerful legal figure in the story, Beverly’s return points to higher-stakes courtroom battles. Expect some serious legal wrangling ahead.
9. Clayton James as Chuck Grant
Chuck’s quirky personality and complicated connection with the firm always make for great subplots. His expected return is good news for those who love a bit of light-hearted distraction.
10. Jeffrey Nordling as Harry
Todd’s estranged dad returning? Oh yes. This means Season 2 might explore even more family drama. And we’re here for it.
11. Elizabeth Alderfer as Claudia
Claudia might not be center stage all the time, but her quiet role in shaping Todd’s world shouldn’t be underestimated. Her return could signal some hidden emotional arcs.
What Their Return Means for Season 2’s Storylines
These returning cast members mean one thing: Season 2 is going deeper. More character growth, unexpected partnerships, and family secrets are likely to unfold.
Expect:
-
More courtroom showdowns with real stakes
-
Sibling drama between Todd and Allison
-
Romantic tension (hello again, Susan)
-
Family confrontations (especially with Harry in the picture)
-
Big laughs thanks to Lyle and Francey
New Dynamics, Same Dysfunction
Let’s face it: this family is a beautiful mess. Season 2 will likely push the boundaries even more. Margaret’s professional standards vs. Todd’s street smarts? Still clashing. But now, with new cases and old wounds resurfacing, the emotional stakes will be even higher.
Room for Growth: Unanswered Questions From Season 1
Remember how Season 1 ended with a few unresolved issues?
-
Will Todd finally gain his mom’s full trust?
-
Is a real romance between Todd and Susan possible?
-
Can Allison fix her marriage—or will she end it?
With the returning cast ready to pick up where they left off, we’ll finally get answers.
Why Fans Should Be Excited
Let’s keep it real: the show wouldn’t work without this cast. Their chemistry is electric. Each actor brings nuance and humor that turns every episode into a binge-worthy event.
And if you’ve seen the behind-the-scenes camaraderie, you know this cast is as tight off-screen as they are on-screen. That’s rare—and it shows in the final product.
Behind the Scenes: Cast Reactions to Season 2
Several cast members have already teased Season 2 on social media, and the excitement is palpable.
Skylar Astin posted: “Let’s do this again. Season 2, we’re coming for ya.”
Marcia Gay Harden shared a selfie in character captioned: “Margaret’s not done yet.”
Clearly, they’re just as ready as the fans.
Can We Expect Guest Stars?
While nothing is confirmed yet, whispers suggest new guest stars could bring fresh energy to Season 2. That means new cases, new personalities, and new chaos.
Where and When to Watch
Season 2 of So Help Me Todd will return on CBS and be available to stream on Paramount+. Stay tuned for an official release date—but expect it sometime this fall.
Conclusion: This Cast Comeback Is Everything
The return of these 11 cast members isn’t just exciting—it’s a promise. A promise that So Help Me Todd will keep doing what it does best: delivering a unique blend of legal drama, emotional storytelling, and laugh-out-loud moments.
So, whether you’re here for the courtroom conflicts, the romantic tension, or the family chaos, one thing’s clear: Season 2 is going to be unforgettable.
