Jordan let Weeks “steer the boat” when it came to wedding planning because he wanted it to be “a perfect day for her,” with hopes it would be “everything she could’ve imagined and more.” For Weeks, it was “truly a dream come true” to plan her wedding alongside the in-house coordinator, MadLove Events.

What the couple of four years immediately agreed on was that their nuptials needed to be “memorable and intimate.”

“Family is really important to us, and being surrounded by them fills our cup,” Weeks says, with Jordan adding, “I didn’t have any must-haves other than having our families celebrate with us.”

Before their ceremony — which was officiated by their hometown pastor, Tony Pierce — Jordan and Weeks privately exchanged handwritten vows. During their ceremony, they highlighted their Christian faith and “gratitude to Jesus” by partaking in communion.

Weeks walked down the aisle accompanied by her father as CeCe Winan’s “Goodness of God,” covered by violinist Alan Milan, played. She wore a wedding dress designed by Valentini that made her “feel like a real-life princess.” Later in the night, she changed into an “elegant” shorter dress that easily allowed her to “dance all night.”

Jordan had a second look too, slipping into “a pair of Wranglers, pearl snap shirt and cowboy boots that have seen better days.”

For the Young Sheldon alum, marriage means having “a best friend for life.”

“It means through thick and thin, she is the one till death do us part,” he tells PEOPLE. “And you know what, I might even look around for her after that in heaven.”