When Hollywood Drama Turns Real
Hollywood is no stranger to controversy, but the recent lawsuit involving the film Horizon: An American Saga – Chapter 2 has stunned many. Stunt performer Devyn LaBella alleges she was forced into a violent, unscripted rape scene directed by Kevin Costner without her consent or proper protocol. This explosive accusation has sent shockwaves through the industry and opened up serious conversations about on-set safety and consent.
What Is Horizon 2? Understanding the Film and Its Context
Horizon 2 is the sequel in a planned four-part Western epic helmed by Kevin Costner. This passion project has been both highly anticipated and fraught with challenges, including production delays and mixed public reception. Costner, who also stars, is deeply involved in every facet of the filmmaking process, making these allegations all the more impactful.
Who Is Devyn LaBella? A Closer Look at the Stunt Performer
Devyn LaBella is a seasoned stuntwoman with credits on major productions. Her expertise in performing dangerous sequences and doubling for leading actresses has earned her respect—until now. She claims that during filming, she was subjected to an unscripted and traumatic scene that crossed every boundary of professional conduct.
The Allegations: What Happened on Set?
According to LaBella’s lawsuit, on May 2, 2023, Kevin Costner directed a scene that was not in the script—a rape scene involving her character being pinned down and physically violated without prior warning or consent. She says this happened repeatedly over multiple takes without an intimacy coordinator present, violating industry rules and personal boundaries.
SAG-AFTRA Rules: The Gold Standard for On-Set Safety
The Screen Actors Guild‐American Federation of Television and Radio Artists (SAG-AFTRA) has clear protocols for intimate scenes, including giving performers 48 hours’ notice, requiring consent, limiting crew presence, and mandating an intimacy coordinator. LaBella alleges these rules were ignored, which could be a serious breach of contract and safety.
The Emotional and Professional Toll
LaBella’s claim goes beyond just the physical act—she reports trauma, emotional distress, and ongoing therapy for PTSD symptoms stemming from the incident. She also alleges retaliation, stating she was excluded from future projects related to the franchise and blacklisted, severely affecting her career trajectory.
Kevin Costner’s Defense: Denial and Counterarguments
Costner’s legal team denies all allegations, asserting that LaBella consented to the scene and was in good spirits afterward. They present texts showing gratitude and enthusiasm from LaBella and maintain that the scene was scripted, rehearsed, and handled professionally.
The Contested Evidence: Text Messages and Witness Statements
Despite Costner’s defense, LaBella submitted text messages describing the experience as an “abomination” and questioning the lack of an intimacy coordinator. These messages fuel the claim that the scene was both unplanned and distressing, suggesting possible abuse of power.
Why This Lawsuit Could Change Hollywood
The case highlights persistent problems in the entertainment industry around consent, performer safety, and power dynamics. It puts pressure on studios to enforce intimacy protocols and prioritize the wellbeing of every cast and crew member, especially stunt performers who often work behind the scenes.
Retaliation Claims and Their Impact on Industry Practices
LaBella’s allegations of retaliation shine a light on how speaking up can sometimes harm careers, emphasizing the need for better protections and whistleblower policies in Hollywood to safeguard workers who report misconduct.
Legal Implications: What’s at Stake?
The lawsuit will explore whether SAG-AFTRA protocols were violated, if LaBella truly consented, and whether Costner abused his authority. The verdict could set significant legal precedents affecting contracts, production practices, and industry accountability.
Public Opinion: Divided Views on the Case
Reactions vary widely. Some support LaBella’s courage to speak out and push for safer sets, while others question the claims and back Costner’s denial. This division reflects ongoing challenges in how society addresses allegations of on-set misconduct.
Comparing Past On-Set Abuse Allegations
This case fits into a broader pattern of allegations in Hollywood, where powerful figures face accusations of exploitation. Each new case adds momentum to calls for industry-wide reforms.
Future of On-Set Intimacy Protocols
The spotlight on this lawsuit is accelerating discussions about mandatory intimacy coordinators, better performer education, and stricter enforcement of consent in film and TV production.
How the Film Industry Is Responding
Studios and unions are paying close attention. Some have started revising guidelines, increasing training, and strengthening safeguards, signaling a potential cultural shift prompted in part by cases like this.
Personal Stories: The Importance of Supporting Survivors
Beyond the legal battle, LaBella’s story resonates as a call to listen, believe, and support performers who face harassment or abuse—vital for healing and preventing future incidents.
What’s Next in the Lawsuit? Anticipated Developments
The case will likely involve depositions, testimonies, and detailed examination of production records. Industry insiders will watch closely for how courts weigh evidence and interpret protocols.
Final Thoughts: A Call for Respect and Safety in Hollywood
Whether this lawsuit ends in settlement, dismissal, or trial, it spotlights critical issues in the entertainment world. Respect for consent, strict adherence to safety rules, and accountability for all cast and crew must be non-negotiable moving forward.
Conclusion
The Horizon 2 lawsuit is a watershed moment. It forces Hollywood to confront uncomfortable truths about power, consent, and safety on set. For Devyn LaBella, it’s a fight for justice and dignity. For the industry, it’s a chance to evolve and protect those who bring stories to life—safely and respectfully.
FAQs
1. What are the main allegations in the Horizon 2 lawsuit?
The stunt performer alleges she was forced to perform a violent, unscripted rape scene without consent, rehearsal, or an intimacy coordinator present.
2. Did Kevin Costner respond to the claims?
Yes, Costner’s team denies the allegations, stating the scene was rehearsed and consensual, and that the stunt performer was cooperative throughout.
3. What rules govern intimate scenes on film sets?
SAG-AFTRA requires 48-hour notice, performer consent, limited crew, and an intimacy coordinator for scenes involving simulated sex or violence.
4. How has this lawsuit impacted the stunt performer’s career?
She claims retaliation and blacklisting, which harmed her ability to work on future projects related to the franchise.
5. Could this case lead to changes in Hollywood?
Absolutely. It may prompt stricter enforcement of intimacy protocols and better protections for performers against abuse and retaliation.
