Justin Hartley: Hollywood’s “Heartbreaker” With Three Marriages and a Trail of Famous Romances

The Handsome Star With a Complicated Love Life

Justin Hartley has long been known for his smoldering good looks, undeniable charm, and a string of successful roles in television and film. But beyond the screen, the This Is Us star has also earned a reputation as one of Hollywood’s most talked-about heartthrobs—not just for his performances, but for his romantic history. With three marriages and numerous high-profile relationships, Hartley has developed the persona of a man who captures hearts as effortlessly as he breaks them.

His First Marriage: A Young Love in Soap Opera World

Hartley’s first marriage was to his Passions co-star Lindsay Korman. The couple met on set in the early 2000s and quickly fell in love. They got engaged in 2003 and tied the knot the following year. Together, they had a daughter, Isabella, born in 2004.

For a while, their union seemed strong, with Hartley often praising his wife in interviews. But by 2012, the couple quietly filed for divorce, citing irreconcilable differences. Despite the split, Hartley and Korman have maintained an amicable co-parenting relationship for the sake of their daughter.

The Chrishell Stause Era: A Hollywood Love Story Gone Public

In 2014, Hartley began dating actress and real estate agent Chrishell Stause, known for her role in Selling Sunset. The pair became a fan-favorite couple, regularly attending red carpet events and posting loved-up photos on social media. They married in an elegant ceremony in 2017, surrounded by friends, family, and fellow celebrities.

But their relationship came to a shocking halt in 2019 when Hartley filed for divorce—allegedly without warning. Chrishell later revealed on Selling Sunset that she found out about the filing via text message just 45 minutes before the news went public. The drama played out across reality TV and tabloids, with fans overwhelmingly supporting Stause and painting Hartley as a cold and impulsive heartbreaker.

Marriage Number Three: Sofia Pernas Enters the Picture

Not long after his split with Stause, Hartley was spotted with actress Sofia Pernas, his former co-star from The Young and the Restless. The pair kept their relationship quiet until they confirmed it in 2021 by making a red carpet appearance together. That same year, they revealed they had secretly gotten married.

Fans were divided—some were happy to see Hartley find happiness again, while others criticized the speed at which he moved on from Stause. Despite the public scrutiny, Hartley and Pernas have appeared close and supportive, often posting about each other on social media and attending events hand-in-hand.

The Hollywood “Heartbreaker” Label

With three marriages in under 20 years, it’s no surprise that Justin Hartley has earned the unofficial title of Hollywood’s “serial heartbreaker.” Whether fair or not, the media has often portrayed him as someone who falls in love fast and moves on even faster. His relationships—with beautiful, talented women from the industry—have only added fuel to that image.

Some see him as unlucky in love, while others view him as emotionally guarded or impulsive. Either way, Hartley remains one of the most talked-about bachelors-turned-husbands-turned-bachelor-again in Hollywood.

What Lies Ahead?

As of now, Hartley seems happily settled with Sofia Pernas. But Hollywood is ever-changing, and so is the romantic landscape of its stars. With a thriving career—currently headlining CBS’s Tracker—and a renewed presence in the spotlight, all eyes remain on Justin Hartley, both on and off the screen.

Whether he’s chasing fugitives in Tracker or navigating the complexities of love in real life, Justin Hartley continues to captivate audiences with every chapter of his story.

4.5/5 - (4 votes)