While Tracker Season 2 delivered shocking twists and edge-of-your-seat drama, it also left fans with plenty of bittersweet feelings. For every mystery solved, there were emotional losses and revelations that stung long after the finale. Here are the biggest regrets and heartbreaking moments audiences felt during Season 2.
1. The Departure of Velma and Bobby
Perhaps the hardest pill to swallow was knowing that Abby McEnany’s Velma and Eric Graise’s Bobby won’t be returning in Season 3. Throughout Season 2, the pair became fan favorites—their humor, loyalty, and brains balanced Colter’s intensity. Viewers regret that their arcs didn’t get a more fitting send-off and wish they had more closure with the team.
2. The Truth About Ashton Shaw’s Death
The reveal that **Otto Waldron killed Colter’s father Ashton—at the request of Colter’s mother Mary—**was one of the most shocking moments of the season. For fans, it was also devastating. The idea that Colter’s mother could be tied to his father’s death turned the Shaw family dynamic upside down, leaving a painful sense of betrayal that fans are still grappling with.
3. Russell and Colter’s Fragile Brotherhood
Viewers were thrilled when Russell Shaw (Jensen Ackles) appeared, but Season 2 showed just how fractured the brothers’ relationship really is. Instead of reconciliation, fans got clashes, mistrust, and unresolved tension. Many regret that there wasn’t more time to see them truly work together as a family unit.
4. The Wooden Carving Mystery
Fans were intrigued by the wooden carving Ashton left behind, but Season 2 ended without clear answers. While the mystery sets up future storylines, viewers regret that this emotional clue to Colter’s father was left dangling instead of providing even a hint of resolution.
5. The Bittersweet Tone of the Finale
The Season 2 finale, “Echo Ridge,” gave fans action and answers, but it also carried a sense of loss. Colter may have exposed a trafficking ring and uncovered more about his father’s past, but the emotional toll was heavy. Instead of closure, the ending left fans with regret, sorrow, and an uneasy curiosity about what’s to come.
Tracker Season 2 gave audiences suspense, action, and unforgettable twists—but it also broke their hearts. From beloved characters leaving to family secrets too painful to ignore, fans ended the season both thrilled and deeply regretful.
And maybe that’s exactly why they can’t wait for Season 3: because the pain makes the story feel real, and the hope for healing is stronger than ever.
