The cast of Chicago P.D. has always been known for their tight-knit dynamic both on and off screen, and a recent reunion photo has once again proven just how strong that bond remains. Marina Squerciati, who plays Officer Kim Burgess, recently sent fans into a frenzy when she shared a playful post teasing her co-star Tracy Spiridakos’ interaction with Jesse Lee Soffer, sparking laughs and plenty of speculation in the fandom.
In the snapshot, the three actors—Squerciati, Spiridakos, and Soffer—were seen enjoying each other’s company during a get-together that brought back several familiar faces from the One Chicago universe. What caught fans’ attention, however, was Squerciati’s caption. With tongue firmly in cheek, she hinted at a lighthearted rivalry by referencing the 1998 Brandy and Monica hit “The Boy Is Mine,” suggesting Spiridakos might be “eyeing” Soffer.
The remark was, of course, made in jest, but it didn’t take long for the photo and comment to go viral among Chicago P.D. enthusiasts. Social media quickly lit up with fans reminiscing about the on-screen chemistry between Spiridakos’ character, Detective Hailey Upton, and Soffer’s Detective Jay Halstead. Their relationship, one of the most beloved in the series, came to an emotional halt when Soffer departed the show in season 10. The playful reunion photo reignited conversations about their characters’ romance and even sparked wishful thinking about Soffer possibly making another return.
Squerciati’s playful tone is nothing new for the actress, who has built a reputation for her quick wit and behind-the-scenes humor. Her ability to poke fun while celebrating her colleagues resonates with fans who admire the genuine camaraderie among the cast. In an industry where on-screen chemistry often fades once the cameras stop rolling, Chicago P.D.’s stars have maintained connections that extend far beyond the set.
For Spiridakos, the reunion was particularly meaningful as she prepares to exit the series in its upcoming season. Having joined the show in season four, Spiridakos has become a cornerstone of the ensemble, carrying some of its most emotionally complex storylines. Her impending departure has already left fans bracing for change, but her reunion with Soffer offered a nostalgic reminder of the years they spent as one of Chicago P.D.’s central couples.
Meanwhile, Soffer’s presence in the photo fueled speculation once again about whether he might reprise his role in some capacity. Since leaving Chicago P.D., he has directed episodes of the series, keeping his connection to the One Chicago world alive. While no official word has surfaced about his return as Halstead, fans remain hopeful—and the reunion photo only amplified those hopes.
Ultimately, the playful post serves as more than just lighthearted fun; it underscores the enduring friendships that have made Chicago P.D. a fan favorite for over a decade. Whether or not the teasing turns into anything more on screen, one thing is clear: the bonds between the cast members remain unshakable, and fans will always be eager to catch a glimpse of those off-duty reunions.
