The Blue Bloods universe is heading in a bold new direction with Boston Blue, a spinoff centered on Donnie Wahlberg’s beloved character, Detective Danny Reagan. But while fans are thrilled about the continuation of Danny’s story, not everyone is happy with the latest news: the spinoff is bringing back a Reagan family member that many viewers didn’t expect — and some are calling it the “wrong” choice.
According to early reports, producers of Boston Blue have confirmed the return of a Reagan relative to stand alongside Danny in the new series. While this move was meant to honor the family connections that made Blue Bloods such a hit, the announcement has left fans divided. Some had hoped to see other familiar Reagan faces return — particularly those who had more direct influence on Danny’s personal and professional journey.
Social media erupted soon after the news broke, with one fan posting, “Why bring back that character when we’ve been waiting for [another Reagan] to return for years?” Another added, “This feels like a missed opportunity. The dynamic could’ve been so much stronger with a different Reagan in the mix.”
Despite the backlash, CBS and the creative team behind the spinoff are defending their decision. Insiders suggest that this particular Reagan’s return will serve a deeper narrative purpose, allowing Danny’s story to evolve in ways that audiences haven’t seen before. “It’s about exploring family bonds from a different angle,” one source explained. “Danny’s relationship with this Reagan is more complicated, and that’s where the drama lies.”
Still, longtime fans of Blue Bloods know that the Reagan family legacy is at the heart of the franchise, and not everyone will agree on which member deserves the spotlight. For now, Wahlberg’s infectious enthusiasm for the project — as seen in his recent behind-the-scenes videos — continues to drive excitement for the spinoff, even among skeptical viewers.
Whether this controversial choice pays off remains to be seen, but one thing is clear: Boston Blue isn’t afraid to take risks. As the series moves closer to its premiere, audiences will be watching closely to see if the return of this Reagan family member strengthens the storytelling — or sparks even more debate.
