9 Biggest Unanswered Questions & Mysteries After The Georgie & Mandy’s First Marriage Season 1 Finale

Warning! SPOILERS about Georgie & Mandy’s First Marriage season 1, episodes 21 and 22 ahead.

The Georgie & Mandy’s First Marriage season 1 finale brilliantly set up the upcoming season 2, leaving some key questions unanswered while also letting a group of storylines finally be tackled, after the Young Sheldon spinoff briefly mentioned them throughout First Marriage season 1. Two major developments drove the story forward in Georgie & Mandy’s First Marriage season 1, episodes 21 and 22: Mandy’s promotion to full-time weather girl, which also revealed she had worked for months with her ex-boyfriend Scott, and Fagenbacher’s proposal to buy McAllister Auto & Tires from Jim, whose serious consideration of the offer angered Georgie.

With both developments centering on the McAllisters and the Coopers, most of the unanswered questions inevitably stem from where those storylines left all Georgie & Mandy’s First Marriage characters after season 1’s finale. Georgie & Mandy’s First Marriage season 1’s general direction also heavily influenced its remaining mysteries, especially in relation to the Young Sheldon characters who already appeared in Georgie & Mandy’s First Marriage or have yet to do so. This leaves Georgie & Mandy’s First Marriage season 2 with multiple storylines to unpack based on what First Marriage season 1, Young Sheldon and The Big Bang Theory established.

9Is McAllister Auto & Tires The Start Of Georgie’s Dr. Tire?

Georgie Never Mentions The Start Of His Business Empire In TBBT

Image via CBS

Older Georgie’s introduction in The Big Bang Theory season 11, episode 23 presented him as a successful entrepreneur to everyone’s eyes except Sheldon’s, who continued to see him only as the older brother who picked on him. Dr. Tire was presented in that instance as Georgie’s tire chain that expanded all over Texas, but The Big Bang Theory or Young Sheldon never revealed what got Georgie to that point.

Georgie and Ruben buying McAllister Auto & Tires from Jim in Georgie & Mandy’s First Marriage season 1’s ending could very much coincide with the start of his business empire, with no more information being available about it. However, Georgie and Ruben’s venture could also be just a starting point, making Dr. Tire something Georgie creates on his own in the future after gaining experience with McAllister Auto & Tires.

8Do Mandy & Scott Really Not Have Feelings For One Another Anymore?

Their Interactions Seem To Hint Otherwise Despite Mandy’s Assurances

Image via CBS

While the boyfriend with whom Mandy worked was something audiences and Georgie knew, Scott only made his surprise first appearance in Georgie & Mandy’s First Marriage season 1’s finale. Mandy hiding from everyone that she had been working with Scott in Medford for months, despite doing so on-and-off, could have already sounded particularly evasive, but their interactions made her lies even more worrisome.

Indeed, although Mandy maintained that there was nothing between her and Scott, and she wouldn’t jeopardize her marriage and family, her and Scott’s exchange about his fiancée not knowing anything about her in Georgie & Mandy’s First Marriage season 1’s ending was odd and too quickly glossed over. Coupled with Mandy and Scott’s awkward interactions, they might very well have lied about it, making everything more complicated when they see one another often in First Marriage season 2.

7What Will Jim Do Now That He Sold The Shop & Is Retired?

Jim’s Retirement Happened Very Fast & Out Of The Blue

McAllister Auto & Tires has been the setting for so many of Jim and Georgie’s bonding moments, along with being extremely important for the McAllisters and Jim in particular, who often opposed Georgie’s attempts at modernizing it in Georgie & Mandy’s First Marriage season 1. Jim considering selling the shop and retiring was a bolt out of the blue in First Marriage season 1’s finale, as he never hinted at working toward that.

Jim spending most of his time at the auto shop in season 1 also raises a major question about how he will spend his time in Georgie & Mandy’s First Marriage season 2. After all, the few times Audrey and Jim were both home for the holidays, bickering was extremely common. Jim’s retirement will inevitably change the newfound stability at the McAllisters, making what he’ll do with his time a mystery for First Marriage season 2 to solve.

6Are Mandy & Georgie Ever Moving Past Rehashing Their Debt & Age Problems During Fights?

Georgie & Mandy’s Fights Always Lead To Those Recriminations

No matter the topic of their fight, First Marriage season 1’s finale proved that Mandy and Georgie always resort to the same type of recriminations when in a corner. Indeed, their fight after Mandy told Georgie the truth about Scott being her boss again prompted her to call him childish, just as Georgie used Mandy’s credit card debt against Mandy after she asked questions about his plan to buy McAllister Tires.

Georgie and Mandy defended their age gap in First Marriage season 1 to others, but its return in every fight points to their not having it truly accepted. We already know from the title and Big Bang Theory that Georgie and Mandy will eventually split up, but it will hopefully be for a different reason rather than something they have been fighting about since Young Sheldon.

5How Will Fagenbacher Try To Sink Georgie & Ruben’s Business?

Fagenbacher’s Threat Sounds Ominous In First Marriage Season 1’s Finale

Image via CBS

Fred Fagenbacher’s introduction in Georgie & Mandy’s First Marriage season 1, episode 11 painted him as a thorn in Jim’s side both for their history with Audrey and Georgie briefly going to work for him, making his proposal to buy McAllister Tires unexpected to say the least. Fagenbacher’s reaction to Georgie and Ruben buying the store instead is even more puzzling, given his threats to drive them out of business.

Why Fagenbacher wanted to buy Jim’s auto shop now was already a mystery, but his taking Georgie and Ruben buying it so personally hints at a good reason, or at least at a strong belief they might be a threat to his company. Hopefully, Georgie & Mandy’s First Marriage season 2 will explain why Fagenbacher is so intent on defeating Georgie and Ruben and what he will do to achieve that.

4Is Missy Going To Behave In Georgie & Mandy’s First Marriage Season 2?

First Marriage Season 1 Showed Only 1 Side Of Missy

Missy appeared several times in Georgie & Mandy’s First Marriage season 1, but every time she did, only her rebellious side was shown. The Big Bang Theory and Young Sheldon had already established Missy’s “dumb teenager” phase as something happening after George Sr.’s death, but First Marriage season 1 not showing Missy’s perspective makes its treatment of her particularly unfair.

Missy’s return in Georgie & Mandy’s First Marriage season 2 is likely, based on season 1’s developments. However, whether Missy will behave differently, or more insight into what she’s thinking is given, is a mystery that the sophomore season of the Young Sheldon spinoff will have to solve.

3Is Connor & Chloe’s Romance Going To Last?

The Couple Was Among The Most Welcomed Unexpected Developments In First Marriage

Connor proved to be one of the best discoveries in Georgie & Mandy’s First Marriage season 1, lightening the mood during the most difficult fights and all-in-all providing a welcome oddity to the mundane problems of the McAllisters. Connor’s relationship with Chloe only made his character more well-rounded, making their return in First Marriage season 2 one of the things to look forward to more eagerly.

With Chloe first appearing in Georgie & Mandy’s First Marriage season 1, episode 15, her and Connor’s relationship couldn’t have been under the spotlight too often. Hopefully, Georgie & Mandy’s First Marriage season 2 will bring Connor and Chloe back and give them more hurdles to work through and come out of stronger, even if First Marriage season 1’s finale didn’t offer any hints about the state of their relationship.

2Will Sheldon Finally Make An Appearance In Georgie & Mandy’s First Marriage Season 2?

TBBT & Young Sheldon’s Genius Has Only Been Mentioned In First Marriage

The biggest absence from Georgie & Mandy’s First Marriage season 1 was Sheldon, after the socially inept genius had been a focus of both The Big Bang Theory and Young Sheldon. Georgie & Mandy’s First Marriage’s focus on Georgie and Mandy’s life in Texas and Sheldon moving away to California give a good reason for his absence, as well as letting the spinoff find its footing without him hogging all the attention.

However, with many key and secondary characters of Young Sheldon returning in Georgie & Mandy’s First Marriage season 1, including George Sr. despite his death, Sheldon’s absence is shaping up to be one of First Marriage’s biggest mysteries. The Young Sheldon spinoff proved it doesn’t need the socially inept genius’s presence to succeed, but his presence would nevertheless be welcome, especially given how much time has passed since Sheldon was last seen.

1Which Other Young Sheldon Characters Can Return In Georgie & Mandy’s First Marriage Season 2?

First Marriage Season 1 Saw Plenty Of Central & Secondary Characters Return

Georgie & Mandy’s First Marriage season 1 saw Missy, Mary, Meemaw and Dale return more often than anyone else, but it also managed to include Pastor Jeff, Coach Wilkins, Ms. Hutchins and even George Cooper Sr. in the form of Georgie’s nightmares when ill. It’s highly likely that the Coopers will return as recurring guest stars in Georgie & Mandy’s First Marriage season 2 as well.

First Marriage season 1’s finale would also warrant Mary’s increased presence in Georgie & Mandy’s First Marriage season 2, after she offered her house as collateral to get Georgie the loan to buy McAllister Tires. This alone would make Mary’s return a certainty. Missy’s rebelliousness could also make a Principal Petersen cameo work, but the safest bet for which Young Sheldon characters could return in Georgie & Mandy’s First Marriage season 2 is undoubtedly the Coopers.