Every long-running series eventually reaches a point where fans start looking backward as much as forward. And when conversations turn to potential returns, two names often come up: Fiona and Antonia. Both left distinct impressions, but for very different reasons — which is exactly why the debate remains so divided.
Fiona represents emotional familiarity. Her presence was tied closely to character-driven storytelling, quieter moments, and relationships that felt lived-in. A return from Fiona wouldn’t just revive an old arc — it would restore a certain emotional rhythm the show has gradually moved away from. For fans who value continuity and depth, her comeback feels like unfinished business.
Antonia, on the other hand, symbolizes disruption. Her story brought tension, unpredictability, and a sharper edge to the narrative. If she were to return, it wouldn’t be about comfort — it would be about conflict. Antonia’s presence has the potential to challenge established dynamics and force characters out of their emotional comfort zones.
That’s what makes the choice so difficult.
Do you want a return that feels like coming home — or one that feels like opening a door you probably shouldn’t? Nostalgia versus momentum. Resolution versus complication.
Both Fiona and Antonia offer something the show could use. But in a story that can only move forward, not every past chapter can be reopened.
So if the decision were yours:
Which actress would you rather see return — Fiona or Antonia? And what do you hope that return would change?
