The end of Blue Bloods may feel like the closing of an era, but for many fans, it also feels like the beginning of a new conversation. With CBS preparing to launch Boston Blue, viewers are already speculating about how this new chapter could stay connected to the legacy that Blue Bloods spent years building. One question keeps popping up across social media and fan forums: which Blue Bloods characters should make the move from New York to Boston?
Spin-offs live or die by familiarity. Audiences are far more willing to invest in a new show when it feels emotionally connected to something they already love. Boston Blue has the advantage of existing in the same universe as Blue Bloods, which opens the door for character transfers that feel organic rather than forced. A few familiar faces could instantly ground the series, giving viewers a reason to tune in from day one.
Danny Reagan is often the first name fans mention when discussing a potential move. His gritty, emotionally charged approach to police work feels tailor-made for a city like Boston, where tension, tradition, and street-level crime could play a major role in shaping the show’s tone. Danny thrives in conflict, and a new department with unfamiliar rules and leadership could challenge him in ways Blue Bloods no longer can. A transfer prompted by internal pressure, personal burnout, or a high-profile case would feel believable and compelling.
Jamie Reagan is another strong candidate, but for very different reasons. Where Danny brings intensity, Jamie brings balance. He understands procedure, leadership, and the moral weight of the badge. In Boston Blue, Jamie could serve as a bridge between old-school policing and modern law enforcement, offering a thoughtful counterpoint to more aggressive tactics. His character has always evolved, and a move to Boston could push that growth even further, especially if he steps into a leadership or specialized role.
Erin Reagan’s presence would expand Boston Blue beyond the streets and into the courtroom. Police dramas often forget that justice does not end with an arrest, and Erin’s prosecutorial perspective adds depth and realism. A federal appointment or interstate legal initiative could easily place her in Boston, where she would raise the stakes by forcing difficult ethical decisions. Her storylines would naturally attract viewers who appreciate legal drama layered on top of crime-solving.
Some fans argue that Anthony Abetemarco would be the smartest supporting character to bring over. He is sharp, sarcastic, and emotionally grounded, making him the kind of character who enhances every scene he is in. Anthony has always been more than comic relief; he represents loyalty, conscience, and quiet strength. In Boston Blue, he could quickly become a fan favorite all over again.
Maria Baez is another character many viewers feel deserves more attention. Throughout Blue Bloods, she proved herself to be observant, empathetic, and deeply competent, yet she was often underused. A move to Boston could finally place her at the center of major storylines, allowing her to grow as both an investigator and a person. Her calm presence would balance the chaos that inevitably comes with a new, high-stakes series.
Eddie Janko’s future is also worth considering. While her story in New York has been closely tied to personal relationships, Boston Blue could offer her a fresh professional chapter. A transfer tied to training, tactical operations, or leadership development would allow Eddie to redefine herself in a new environment. For longtime fans, watching her navigate independence in a new city would be both realistic and engaging.
Not every character, however, should make the jump. Frank Reagan is the heart of Blue Bloods, and moving him to Boston would risk weakening the emotional foundation of the original series. Some characters are meant to stay where their legacy was built, and Frank’s story deserves a respectful conclusion rather than a relocation.
The key to Boston Blue’s success will be restraint. Bringing over too many familiar faces could make the show feel like Blue Bloods in disguise, rather than a bold new chapter. Carefully chosen characters with clear narrative purpose will help the series establish its own identity while still honoring its roots.
Ultimately, Boston Blue has a rare opportunity. By selecting the right characters to carry forward, CBS can satisfy loyal fans while attracting a new audience. The move from New York to Boston is more than a change of scenery—it’s a chance to explore new moral dilemmas, deeper conflicts, and a darker, more modern tone. The real question is not whether characters should move, but which ones are ready to evolve with the story.
