The internet is spiraling after a viral fan theory suggested that The Summer I Turned Pretty may have filmed a secret ending for Conrad Fisher and Isabel “Belly” Conklin—and never showed it to the public. While there is no official confirmation from Prime Video or author Jenny Han, the speculation has ignited intense debate across TikTok, Reddit, and X (formerly Twitter).
Below is a breakdown of what fans are saying—and why this rumor refuses to disappear.
A “Lost” Scene That Was Supposed to Change Everything
According to online discussions, some viewers believe the production team filmed an alternate or extended ending featuring Conrad and Belly that was ultimately cut before release. The theory gained traction after fans noticed what they described as “editing gaps” and emotional beats that felt unresolved.
Some claim the pacing of the finale hinted at a larger payoff—possibly a confession, reconciliation, or even a flash-forward moment that would have confirmed their long-term future. However, no behind-the-scenes evidence has surfaced to support the claim.
The Flash-Forward Wedding Theory
One of the most popular rumors suggests that a flash-forward scene exists showing Conrad and Belly years later—possibly engaged or married. Supporters of this theory argue that the show has subtly built toward an “endgame” narrative, and that a future glimpse would align with the romantic tone of the series.
Fans point to the lingering shots, symbolic beach imagery, and dialogue callbacks as “proof” that something bigger may have originally been planned. Others counter that this interpretation may simply be the result of passionate shipping culture.
Clues Hidden in Cast Interviews?
Some fans have dissected cast interviews, claiming that certain responses from Lola Tung or Christopher Briney hinted at emotional scenes that did not fully appear on screen. These interpretations often circulate as short video clips, fueling further speculation.
However, interviews can be edited for time or marketing purposes, and there is no verified statement confirming a removed ending scene.
Why the Rumor Makes Emotional Sense to Fans
For many viewers, Conrad and Belly represent a slow-burn love story built on longing and unfinished conversations. Because their relationship is filled with tension and missed timing, some fans feel a hidden “closure scene” would make narrative sense.
In fandom culture, when a love story feels open-ended, theories tend to fill the gap. The idea of a secret ending offers emotional reassurance to viewers who want definitive confirmation of where the couple stands.
Team Conrad vs. Team Jeremiah: Fueling the Fire
It’s impossible to separate this rumor from the long-running Team Conrad vs. Team Jeremiah debate. Supporters of Conrad often interpret subtle moments as signs that he is the ultimate endgame, while others believe the show deliberately keeps things ambiguous.
A supposed “unaired ending” has become symbolic in that debate—almost like proof waiting to be discovered.
Marketing Strategy or Pure Fan Fiction?
Another angle circulating online suggests that if such a scene exists, it could be saved for a future season, bonus content, or anniversary special. Streaming platforms sometimes hold back extended cuts or deleted scenes for promotional purposes.
That said, there is currently no official evidence that a secret Conrad-and-Belly ending was filmed or shelved.
The Power of Fandom Speculation
Whether true or not, the rumor highlights the cultural impact of The Summer I Turned Pretty. Few teen dramas inspire this level of analysis, frame-by-frame breakdowns, and emotionally invested debate.
Until producers or cast members directly address the speculation, the “secret ending” theory will likely remain what it is today: a compelling piece of internet buzz driven by passionate fans.
For now, Cousins Beach keeps its mysteries—and the fandom keeps refreshing for answers.
