If you’re still feeling the sting of So Help Me Todd’s abrupt cancellation, you’re not alone. The show left us hanging with a jaw-dropping cliffhanger in its finale, and while the bad news is that we won’t get to see these storylines play out, the good news is that series creator Scott Prendergast has shared some intriguing insights about what could have been. Let’s dive into the cliffhanger and explore the tantalizing plans for a potential Season 3!
The Cliffhanger That Left Us Wanting More
The finale of So Help Me Todd was a rollercoaster of emotions. It introduced Merritt Folding, the elusive founding partner of the Wrights’ law firm, just as Todd discovered that his mother, Margaret (played by Marcia Gay Harden), was being framed for Folding’s illegal activities. Prendergast described Folding as the show’s new “Big Bad,” orchestrating chaos from the shadows.
He explained, “Every season was meant to end with a man arriving to complicate things.” In Season 1, it was Harry; in Season 2, it was Folding. This formula added layers to the narrative, setting up a compelling foundation for the show’s future.
The Gamble of a Cliffhanger Ending
Ending a season on a cliffhanger is always a risk. Prendergast acknowledged that when they started Season 2, they had no idea it would be their last. The decision to include the cliffhanger was backed by CBS execs who were just as invested in the show’s potential. “We pitched the whole arc at the beginning of the season,” he said, expressing regret only in hindsight. “I’ll ‘own it’ instead,” he added, channeling his inner optimist.
The cliffhanger not only set up the immediate conflict for the characters but also left viewers hungry for what could come next, making it all the more painful that Season 3 never materialized.
What Was Next for Todd, Judy, and the Crew?
Had So Help Me Todd been renewed, the narrative threads woven throughout Season 2 would have taken exciting turns. Here’s what Prendergast had in mind for our beloved characters.
Todd and Judy’s Relationship Arc
Todd and Judy (Heather Morris) had chemistry that lit up the screen. Their relationship was just beginning to flourish, and Prendergast had grand plans for them. “Judy was an homage to Barbra Streisand’s character in ‘What’s Up Doc?’,” he shared, hinting at deeper connections within the storyline.
In Season 3, Todd and Judy would face complications stemming from Todd’s past actions, including his run-in with Judy’s estranged father, the crooked Judge Brixton. Their love story would continue to evolve, and after three seasons of ups and downs, the duo would experience a shocking twist—Judy would decide to embrace her free spirit and move to Thailand, leaving Todd to navigate life without her.
The Future of Allison
Allison (Madeline Wise) had a rough time in Season 2, and her character was primed for significant development. “Our headline for her was ‘Saturn Returns’,” Prendergast noted. He envisioned a journey of self-discovery for Allison, moving from a state of confusion to clarity.
Prendergast hinted at her exploring P.I. classes, setting the stage for future tension with Todd as she unravels cases. Allison’s trajectory would lead her toward a career as a forensic pathologist, complete with a potential spinoff titled Allison, ME. It would be a show centered around her character, reminiscent of classics like Quincy, M.E., where she solves medical mysteries while navigating her complicated family dynamics.
Susan’s New Chapter
As for Susan (the character played by the brilliant Leslie Silva), she was on the verge of a major career shift. After considering a job offer, she would leave the Wright law firm, but not without making a significant impact. Prendergast envisioned Susan becoming a powerhouse attorney in Portland, ultimately returning to help clear Margaret’s name when Folding’s schemes threatened her.
In the grand tapestry of the series, Susan’s character was poised for growth and empowerment, proving that a strong friendship could transcend professional boundaries.
The Dynamics of Margaret and Beverly
One of the most intriguing potential arcs was the evolving relationship between Margaret and Beverly (also played by Leslie Silva). Initially antagonistic, the two characters would find common ground as they faced off against Folding. “They would have become allies against a common enemy,” Prendergast shared.
This alliance would lead to rich storytelling, revealing more about Beverly’s past and her motives. The show planned to introduce Beverly’s wife, who would add a comedic yet chaotic element to the story. Prendergast had his sights set on Amy Sedaris for the role, hinting at plenty of laughs ahead.
The Complicated Love Life of Margaret
Margaret and Gus’s relationship faced its fair share of trials, especially following the events of the finale. Prendergast shared that trust issues would bubble to the surface, yet the couple’s chemistry would lead to their eventual engagement. Their wedding would even feature a fun twist—a ceremony officiated by Margaret’s son, Lawrence, who would have transitioned into a more prominent role.
Reflecting on Two Seasons of Magic
Looking back on the show, Prendergast expressed pride in various accomplishments, especially moments that highlighted the character dynamics. The heartfelt scenes featuring the three siblings around a fire resonated deeply, showcasing their relationships in a touching light.
“Those moments added a whole new dimension to the show,” he recalled. The series had a knack for blending humor and heartfelt storytelling, leaving viewers invested in the characters’ journeys.
Conclusion: A Heartfelt Farewell
While So Help Me Todd may have concluded with unanswered questions and tantalizing cliffhangers, the passion from its creator and cast shines through. The plans for Season 3 hinted at a rich tapestry of character development, emotional arcs, and intriguing storylines.
As we bid farewell to Todd, Margaret, and the rest of the gang, we’re left with a bittersweet taste—appreciating what we had while mourning what could have been. Fans will hold onto the hope that one day, these characters may find their way back into our lives, whether through a revival or a reboot.
