Simon Cowell has certainly left a lasting impression on X Factor with his infamous, brutally honest critiques. Celebrating his 65th birthday, a look back at his most savage moments reveals just how sharp his tongue can be.
One particularly memorable comment was directed at a contestant from Eastern Europe, where he quipped, “I don’t know what cats being squashed sound like in Lithuania, but I now have a pretty good idea.” His scathing remarks often included historical references, like suggesting that if the contestant had sung poorly 2,000 years ago, they would have faced stoning.
Cowell’s critiques of groups were equally cutting. To one disillusioned group, he stated, “You’re probably the most disillusioned group of people we’ve ever had in this competition… I think individually you’re weak, I think as a group you’re even worse.” He’s also been known to declare a contestant as possibly “the worst singer in the world,” and warned another that their chance of success was akin to him flying to the moon for breakfast.
Despite the harshness, there were moments of genuine praise. Contestants like Stacey Solomon, who captivated him with her rendition of “What A Wonderful World,” earned heartfelt compliments amidst the biting criticism.
Cowell’s legacy as a judge is a mix of brutal honesty and occasional warmth, keeping audiences both entertained and shocked throughout the seasons.