Tracker Season 2 Is Already Setting Itself Up For An Unwinnable Choice (& It Didn’t Have To)
Season 2 of Tracker has continued to push its boundaries, delivering gripping action and tense character-driven drama. However, as the season unfolds, it’s becoming increasingly clear that the show is steering itself toward an unresolvable dilemma. This looming conflict, while potentially dramatic, feels like an unnecessary narrative trap—one that could have been avoided with more careful storytelling.
The Unwinnable Choice Taking Shape
At the heart of this unwinnable scenario is Colton West’s (Justin Hartley) dual loyalty—to his relentless pursuit of justice and his fragile personal life. Throughout the season, Colton has been torn between his duties as a tracker and his attempts to rebuild relationships fractured by his past mistakes. As the stakes rise, it’s evident that he will soon have to make a choice: protect those he loves or stay true to his mission.
This setup is classic for procedural dramas, but in Tracker’s case, the stakes feel artificially inflated. The narrative is pushing Colton toward a situation where neither option allows for a satisfying resolution. Sacrificing his personal life would undermine his journey toward redemption, while abandoning his mission would contradict the core of his character.
Why It Didn’t Have To Be This Way
The real frustration lies in how avoidable this conflict could have been with more nuanced writing. Instead of crafting a binary choice, the show could have explored a middle path where Colton learns to balance his professional obligations with his personal desires.
The problem stems from the writers’ tendency to create overly dramatic stakes at the expense of organic character development. By constantly escalating the tension, Tracker risks alienating viewers who are more invested in seeing Colton grow as a person than watching him face impossible scenarios.
Additionally, the show’s supporting characters haven’t been given enough depth to provide meaningful alternatives or assist in Colton’s struggle. By sidelining key relationships and focusing primarily on Colton’s internal conflict, the narrative has narrowed its scope unnecessarily.
What’s at Stake for Tracker
If Tracker continues down this path, it runs the risk of alienating its fanbase. Viewers are drawn to Colton’s complexity and his quest for redemption, but forcing him into a no-win scenario could make the series feel overly bleak and unsatisfying.
Moreover, the lack of exploration into alternative solutions makes the story less compelling. The best dramas are those that reflect the complexities of real life, where choices are rarely black-and-white. By embracing this complexity, Tracker could elevate its storytelling and give fans a more rewarding viewing experience.
How the Show Can Course-Correct
To avoid the pitfalls of this unwinnable choice, Tracker should focus on building stronger relationships between Colton and the supporting cast. These connections can serve as a foundation for finding creative solutions to his dilemmas. Instead of isolating Colton in his struggle, the show could highlight the importance of teamwork and shared growth.
Additionally, the series should invest more time in exploring the gray areas of Colton’s conflict. Rather than presenting an either-or scenario, the story could delve into the compromises and sacrifices necessary to achieve a more balanced resolution.
Final Thoughts
While Tracker Season 2 is undeniably thrilling, its current trajectory toward an unwinnable choice feels unnecessarily forced. By embracing a more nuanced approach to storytelling and character development, the show can avoid alienating its audience and deliver a more satisfying conclusion. Fans are hopeful that the writers will recognize the opportunity to deepen the narrative and steer Tracker toward a stronger, more layered second half of the season.
