Over the years, Chicago P.D. has seen several notable cast departures, many of which shocked and saddened fans.
Sophia Bush (Erin Lindsay) – Season 4 Sophia Bush’s exit as Detective Erin Lindsay in season 4 was one of the most shocking departures in Chicago P.D. history. Lindsay had been a central character since the show’s first season, and her departure was unexpected. Bush later revealed that her decision to leave was due to personal reasons, including a desire for a healthier work environment. Her exit was written into the show as Lindsay deciding to leave Chicago for a fresh start, which was both emotional and impactful for fans who had followed her character’s journey.
Jesse Lee Soffer (Jay Halstead) – Season 10 Jesse Lee Soffer’s decision to leave Chicago P.D. after playing Jay Halstead for 10 seasons was another blow to fans. Halstead had become a fan favorite, known for his strong moral code and complex relationship with his partner, Hailey Upton. Soffer announced his departure in 2022, revealing that it was his choice to leave the role. His exit came as a shock, as Halstead’s future on the show had seemed secure. His departure was addressed by having Halstead take a job with the Army in Bolivia, giving the character a chance to pursue a new path while still honoring his dedication to law enforcement.
Brian Geraghty (Sean Roman) – Season 4 Brian Geraghty’s exit as Officer Sean Roman in season 4 was another surprising moment for fans of the show. Roman had been a loyal and dedicated member of the Intelligence Unit, and his departure was tied to the character’s emotional and psychological struggles. Roman’s decision to leave the Chicago Police Department was a reflection of his internal battle with the trauma he had endured on the job. Geraghty’s departure allowed the show to shift its focus to other characters and explore new dynamics within the unit.
Marina Squerciati (Kim Burgess) – Possible Future Departure Similarly to Hawkins, there have been hints that Marina Squerciati’s character, Kim Burgess, could leave Chicago P.D. in the future. While Squerciati has been a cornerstone of the series since season 1, her character has faced significant challenges, including trauma and personal loss. Should Burgess ever leave, it would mark the end of a major character arc, and fans would undoubtedly be heartbroken by her departure. However, Squerciati has not confirmed any plans to leave the show, and her character continues to play a major role in current storylines.
Chicago P.D. has seen some dramatic departures over the years, leaving lasting impacts on both the characters and the viewers. These exits have shaped the show in significant ways, and though new characters have come and gone, the legacy of those who left remains a key part of the show’s evolution. The departures of stars like Sophia Bush, Jesse Lee Soffer, and Brian Geraghty will always be remembered as pivotal moments in the series’ history.
