There are some movie roles that become so memorable for an actor’s portrayal that it is hard to imagine any other performer in that part. The idea of a remake alone seems absurd, let alone a recast for a sequel. Sometimes, it can be even hard to accept the notion that the performer we so deeply associate with said role had to audition for it and that they could’ve been replaced by someone else.
These are your Terminators (Arnold Schwarzenegger), your Brides (Uma Thurman), your Professor Snapes (Alan Rickman)… The list goes on. Though it might not seem like it, two characters that definitely belong on this list are Titanic’s Jack Dawson and Rose Dewitt Bukater, played marvelously by Leonardo DiCaprio and Kate Winslet. Jack and Rose’s tragic romance is so deeply rooted in our collective memories that it can be difficult to picture them as mere fictional people who could be played by different actors. Heck, questions about whether Jack and Rose were actually real are among the first suggestions Google gives searchers when they try to look up the 1997 film. But Rose was almost played by an entirely different actress — Gwyneth Paltrow — all because director James Cameron didn’t want to be obvious with his casting choices.
Before ‘Titanic,’ Kate Winslet Made a Name for Herself in Period Pieces
Viewers nowadays have no problem imagining Kate Winslet in more modern roles. After Rose in Titanic, the actress’ most memorable part is probably blue-haired Clementine in Michel Gondry’s 2004 light sci-fi Eternal Sunshine of a Spotless Mind. Even more recently, the actress received Emmy and BAFTA nominations for the role of a rugged small-town detective on HBO’s Mare of Easttown. But not that long ago, Kate Winslet was one of those performers that viewers had trouble picturing in anything but a corset and a hoop skirt. Early in her career, the actress made a name for herself starring in period pieces drawing inspiration from William Shakespeare to Mark Twain.
Kate Winslet’s big silver screen break was in the 1994 period thriller Heavenly Creatures, directed by Peter Jackson. In the movie, the actress stars opposite Melanie Lynskey as part of a duo of inseparable teenage girls are eventually driven to murder when her parents try to put an end to their friendship. The story is based on the Parker-Hulme murder that shook New Zealand in the early 1950s. And, for a while, this would be Winslet’s more “contemporary” role. As soon as she was done with Heavenly Creatures, the actress took the role of a medieval princess in Michael Gottlieb’s A Kid in King Arthur’s Court, a comedy loosely based on Mark Twain’s A Connecticut Yankee in King Arthur’s Court. From the Round Table, Winslet jumped to the English Regency, playing Marianne Dashwood in Ang Lee’s Sense and Sensibility, an adaptation of the classic Jane Austen novel of the same name. Then she went on to play a 19th-century British liberal in Michael Winterbottom’s Jude and Hamlet’s Ophelia in Kenneth Branagh’s version of the Shakespeare play.
James Cameron Almost Cast Gwyneth Paltrow as Rose in ‘Titanic’
All this history in period films should make Kate Winslet perfect for the role of an early-20th-century socialite that falls in love with a poor boy aboard the most infamous line cruiser that ever existed, right? Well, not according to 1997 James Cameron. In an interview with GQ magazine, James Cameron reveals that he felt that casting Winslet as his protagonist would’ve seemed like an exceedingly obvious move. According to Cameron, Winslet was developing a sort of reputation for her historical films, at the time, which earned her the nickname of Corset Kate.
“So I thought ‘Oh, man, this is going to look like the laziest casting in the world”, said the director. Nonetheless, he did agree to meet her and eventually gave her the part. As all of us now know, she was simply fantastic in the role, so there was no other choice for young James Cameron. Still, before Winslet’s audition, the director almost went with someone else entirely for the role: Shakespeare in Love Best Actress Oscar winner and Goop founder Gwyneth Paltrow.
