The soulmate debate inside The Summer I Turned Pretty is far from over.
While some fans insist the story belongs to Belly and Conrad, others are doubling down on a different perspective:
Belly and Jeremiah Fisher are the true soulmates.
And their biggest evidence? The parallels.
Like Mother, Like Child: The “Mini-Me” Connection
Viewers have pointed out that Belly and Jeremiah are often described as their mothers’ mini versions.
Belly mirrors Laurel Park in subtle ways — emotionally perceptive, strong-willed, quietly intense.
Jeremiah reflects Susannah Fisher’s warmth, light, and magnetic social energy.
Put those traits together, and some fans argue you get a natural match.
Like mother, like child. 👩👦👩👧
Two personalities that complement rather than collide.
Parallels Over Passion
Supporters of the Belly/Jeremiah pairing often say their relationship feels balanced. They laugh easily. They communicate more directly. They move in sync.
Where Belly and Conrad Fisher are built on longing and intensity, Belly and Jeremiah share visible parallels in personality and energy.
They’re playful. Expressive. Emotionally open.
For some viewers, that alignment signals soulmate material more than brooding chemistry ever could.
Soulmates or Just Similar?
The heart of the debate comes down to definition.
Is a soulmate someone who mirrors you — someone who feels easy and natural from the start?
Or is it someone who challenges you, changes you, and pulls you into deeper emotional waters?
Fans who champion “Jelly” argue that shared traits, shared warmth, and shared values matter more than dramatic tension. They see Belly and Jeremiah as equals walking side by side.
To them, that’s what real partnership looks like.
Why the Debate Isn’t Ending Anytime Soon
What makes The Summer I Turned Pretty so addictive is that both sides have emotional evidence.
Belly and Conrad have history and intensity.
Belly and Jeremiah have parallels and lightness.
Some see cosmic fate. Others see compatibility.
And maybe that’s the brilliance of the story — it reflects how people define love differently.
Is it fire?
Or is it harmony?
For many fans, the answer is clear: Belly and Jeremiah’s parallels prove they are each other’s soulmates.
For others, the debate continues.
And at Cousins Beach, it always will. 🌊
