One of Chicago P.D.’s greatest strengths is its ability to dive deep into the personal lives and moral struggles of its characters.
Whether it’s Voight’s controversial leadership, Burgess’s resilience, or Ruzek’s ongoing redemption arc, the show excels at creating emotionally charged, character-driven narratives. Yet, too often, this is overshadowed by a heavy focus on case-of-the-week procedural storytelling.
Fans who tune in for the emotional depth and long-term character arcs often feel shortchanged when the show shifts its focus entirely to the crime-solving aspect, leaving personal stories unresolved or rushed. Conversely, procedural enthusiasts sometimes feel bogged down by the weight of ongoing character drama. Striking this balance has always been a challenge for Chicago P.D., but failing to do so risks alienating both sides of its audience.
The lesson is simple: character-driven storytelling and procedural elements don’t have to be mutually exclusive. Shows like The Wire and Breaking Bad have proven that you can have gripping episodic content while still maintaining deeply satisfying character arcs. For Chicago P.D. to thrive in its 12th season, it must fully commit to weaving these two elements together seamlessly.
This is especially important now, as Season 12 introduces new characters and explores pivotal changes within Intelligence. With Marina Squerciati’s potential departure as Kim Burgess, the show has a golden opportunity to delve into how her absence impacts the team emotionally and operationally. Likewise, Voight’s evolving leadership style, shaped by years of controversy, begs for more nuanced exploration.
As Chicago P.D. faces increasing competition from newer and edgier dramas, it cannot afford to rest on its laurels. Fans have become more discerning, craving authenticity and depth in their favorite shows. By committing to a stronger balance between its procedural and personal elements, Chicago P.D. can not only retain its loyal fan base but also attract new viewers looking for a show with heart and grit.
Season 12 is shaping up to be a critical turning point for the series. The new faces in Intelligence, the rumored exits of beloved characters, and the unresolved tensions within the team all present opportunities for the show to evolve. But without learning this vital lesson, Chicago P.D. risks falling into the same traps that have previously hindered its growth.
Despite its flaws, Chicago P.D. has always had the potential to deliver incredible storytelling. The emotional stakes, morally ambiguous dilemmas, and raw performances from its cast have made it a fan favorite for years. Season 12 holds the promise of redemption if the show can finally learn to balance its two strongest elements—character depth and procedural drama.
