When you remove personality, heartbreak, and storyline drama from the equation and focus on one thing only — pure looks — the fandom suddenly becomes even more divided.
So if we’re judging strictly on appearance, who takes it: Conrad or Jeremiah?
Let’s break down what fans are really saying.
Team Conrad: The Eyes, The Hair, The Stare
Supporters of Conrad Fisher don’t hesitate.
It’s the eyes.
It’s the hair.
It’s the way he looks at people.
That intense, quiet stare? The soft half-smile? The corner mole that somehow became its own fan-favorite feature?
For many viewers, Conrad’s appeal isn’t just about symmetry — it’s about presence. He has that brooding, model-off-duty energy that makes even a simple glance feel cinematic.
And while blue eyes are often considered the “classic” heartthrob feature, some fans even admit they don’t usually find blue eyes attractive — yet Conrad somehow makes them reconsider.
That’s power.
Team Jeremiah: Golden Boy Energy
Then there’s Jeremiah Fisher.
The sunshine smile. The beachy glow. The effortless charm.
Jeremiah’s look is brighter, warmer, and more playful. Where Conrad gives mysterious intensity, Jeremiah gives confident ease. He looks like summer personified — tan skin, relaxed posture, that constant ready-to-laugh expression.
For fans who prefer approachable over brooding, Jeremiah wins instantly.
The “I Switched Sides” Effect
Interestingly, some viewers admit they started as Team Jeremiah — at least visually.
But over time, they began noticing Conrad differently. The details became sharper. The expressions hit harder. The subtle features stood out more.
Attraction can evolve, especially when a character’s emotional depth influences how we see them physically.
And then there are the fans who simply refuse to choose.
Because honestly? Both brothers are objectively stunning.
Brooding vs. Bright: What’s Your Type?
The debate ultimately comes down to personal preference:
Do you prefer the quiet, intense, emotionally-charged gaze of Conrad?
Or the warm, golden-retriever charm of Jeremiah?
In The Summer I Turned Pretty, both were clearly designed to make viewers swoon — just in completely different ways.
So… Who Wins on Looks Alone?
If we’re voting strictly on physical appearance, the fandom leans slightly toward Conrad — largely because of those eyes, that smile, and the way he looks at Belly like she’s the only person in the room.
But Jeremiah remains a serious contender, especially for fans who prefer sunshine over storm clouds.
In the end, the real answer might be this:
It depends on your type.
Broody heartthrob or glowing beach prince?
Either way… Cousins Beach clearly has elite genetics.
