Few fictional characters have sparked as much debate as Hardin Scott, the brooding antihero of the After franchise. From his explosive temper to his emotional manipulation, Hardin’s flaws have been dissected by fans and critics alike since After first hit screens. But with After Everything bringing his story full circle, one question continues to divide the fandom: does Hardin truly deserve forgiveness?
In After Everything, we meet a very different Hardin — a man grappling with the wreckage of his past actions. No longer the rebellious, self-destructive college student who used anger as armor, he’s forced to confront the emotional pain he inflicted on those who loved him, especially Tessa Young. The film positions Hardin’s journey as one of accountability and redemption. Gone are the impulsive outbursts; in their place stands a man determined to make amends.
What makes Hardin’s redemption arc compelling is that it’s not instant or easy. His path toward forgiveness isn’t about grand gestures or romantic clichés — it’s about quiet introspection and genuine remorse. The Hardin we see now is writing, reflecting, and even isolating himself, not to wallow, but to understand the depth of his wrongdoings. His book, a key element in After Everything, becomes both confession and catharsis. Through his words, he acknowledges the harm he caused — not just to Tessa, but to himself.
However, forgiveness in this story isn’t a one-way street. Tessa’s journey is equally crucial. Her decision whether or not to forgive Hardin symbolizes reclaiming her own power after years of emotional chaos. The film treats forgiveness not as a reward for Hardin’s suffering but as an act of liberation — for both of them.
Still, fans remain split. Some argue that years of toxic behavior can’t be undone by a few heartfelt apologies. Others believe that growth and change, when sincere, are worthy of a second chance. After all, the After series has always thrived on exploring love’s imperfections — how passion and pain can coexist, and how redemption, while rare, is possible.
Ultimately, After Everything doesn’t demand that we forgive Hardin. It simply asks us to witness his transformation. His redemption isn’t about erasing his past but about learning to live with it. Whether or not he deserves forgiveness is up to the viewer — but what’s clear is that Hardin Scott finally understands that love without accountability isn’t love at all.
