In 1989, Family Matters made its debut on ABC, bringing audiences a fresh take on family life with a comedic twist. Originally a spin-off from Perfect Strangers, the show quickly became a staple of the TGIF lineup and an iconic part of the ’90s TV landscape. The Hollywood Reporter’s review of Family Matters in 1989 was one of the first to analyze the show’s potential and charm. But did it really hit the mark? Let’s dive deep into the 1989 review and explore what made Family Matters stand out.
A New Kind of Family Sitcom
The Winslow Family – A Fresh Perspective on Family Dynamics
Before Family Matters, the idea of a Black middle-class family on TV was still relatively rare. The show introduced the Winslow family: Carl (Reginald VelJohnson), Harriette (Jo Marie Payton), and their two children, Laura and Eddie. It presented the Winslows as relatable, real people dealing with everyday problems, making it a refreshing alternative to other family sitcoms of the time.
The Focus on Relatable Family Issues
The show’s 1989 premiere touched on a wide range of relatable issues—parenting challenges, sibling rivalry, dating, school pressures, and more. The Winslows, despite their traditional family values, dealt with situations that resonated with audiences across all walks of life. What made the show special was that it didn’t present a perfect family but a family who worked through their differences and loved each other.
Steve Urkel: The Game-Changer
An Unexpected Character Who Took Over the Spotlight
While the Winslow family was the core of the show, it was Steve Urkel, portrayed by Jaleel White, who changed everything. Urkel was supposed to be a one-off guest character. However, his nerdy charm, hilarious catchphrases, and slapstick humor quickly made him the breakout star. In fact, the character of Urkel took over the series so much that some fans began referring to the show as “The Steve Urkel Show.”
The Birth of an Iconic Catchphrase
“Did I do that?” became the catchphrase heard everywhere, and it quickly became one of the most recognizable quotes in television history. Urkel’s quirky personality, complete with his oversized glasses and high-pitched voice, made him unforgettable. What started as an oddball character turned into one of TV’s most beloved figures.
Humor With Heart
Blending Comedy and Life Lessons
While Family Matters had its share of silly moments, especially thanks to Urkel, it also offered valuable lessons. The show wasn’t afraid to tackle serious issues such as bullying, peer pressure, and the importance of family. Even when Urkel caused chaos, the episodes typically ended on a heartwarming note, reminding viewers about the importance of love and understanding in a family.
The Dynamic Between Carl and Harriette
The chemistry between Reginald VelJohnson (Carl) and Jo Marie Payton (Harriette) was palpable, and their performances elevated the show. Carl, the loving but tough police officer, and Harriette, the supportive but firm wife, created a balanced dynamic that made their marriage feel authentic and grounded. Together, they navigated the ups and downs of raising children while also dealing with their own personal challenges. Their interactions brought humor and emotional depth to the series, making it stand out in a crowded television landscape.
Cultural Impact of Family Matters
Breaking Ground for Black Families on Primetime TV
Family Matters wasn’t just another family sitcom—it broke new ground by representing Black families in a way that hadn’t been seen on television before. At a time when the representation of Black families was limited, Family Matters painted a picture of an African American family living a full, middle-class life. The show’s impact reached beyond comedy, providing a positive portrayal of Black culture and family values.
Shifting TV Norms in the Late ’80s and Early ’90s
At the time, family sitcoms were dominated by shows like Full House and The Cosby Show. However, Family Matters carved its niche by mixing traditional family values with a unique sense of humor. The Winslows offered a refreshing take on the everyday struggles and triumphs that all families face, making it an instant hit for both Black and mainstream audiences alike.
The 1989 Review: A Prophetic Look at the Show’s Future Success
Critical Response in 1989: What Did The Hollywood Reporter Think?
The Hollywood Reporter’s review of Family Matters in 1989 was cautiously optimistic. Critics acknowledged the show’s potential and praised its focus on family and humor. However, some questioned whether the show could sustain its appeal long-term. The character of Steve Urkel, in particular, was seen as a double-edged sword. While his eccentricities provided a unique comedic angle, there was concern that his popularity might overshadow the rest of the cast.
Did the Review Predict the Show’s Success?
Looking back, it’s clear that Family Matters went on to exceed expectations. While it initially struggled with finding its identity, the show eventually grew into one of the longest-running sitcoms of the 1990s. The Hollywood Reporter’s review hinted at the key ingredients that would make the show a lasting hit—heartfelt family moments and an unforgettable cast of characters, particularly Urkel.
Legacy of Family Matters
The Show’s Impact on Future Sitcoms
The success of Family Matters paved the way for many other Black-led sitcoms in the ’90s, including The Fresh Prince of Bel-Air and Moesha. By providing a platform for Black families to be portrayed in a positive light, Family Matters became a trailblazer in television history.
Enduring Popularity and Cultural Relevance
Even though the show ended in 1998, Family Matters remains relevant in popular culture. Thanks to reruns and streaming platforms, new generations of fans continue to discover the Winslows and their hilarious, heartwarming journey. The show’s impact is still felt today, and characters like Urkel remain iconic figures in TV history.
Conclusion: Family Matters – A Timeless Classic
Looking back at Family Matters in 1989, it’s clear that the show had all the right ingredients for success—relatable family dynamics, unforgettable characters, and a healthy dose of humor and heart. The 1989 review from The Hollywood Reporter may have been cautiously optimistic, but history has proven that Family Matters was more than just a passing fad. It was a sitcom that shaped a generation and left a lasting impact on television.
5 Unique FAQs
Q1: What was the main reason Family Matters became so popular?
A: Family Matters became popular because of its unique blend of humor, heartfelt family moments, and memorable characters like Steve Urkel, who became an instant TV icon.
Q2: Did Family Matters only focus on comedy, or did it tackle serious issues?
A: While the show was comedic, it also tackled important social and family issues like peer pressure, bullying, and self-esteem, all while maintaining a lighthearted tone.
Q3: Why did Steve Urkel become the breakout character of the show?
A: Urkel became the breakout character due to his quirky personality, memorable catchphrases like “Did I do that?” and his unique comedic presence that appealed to both kids and adults.
Q4: How did Family Matters impact the portrayal of Black families on television?
A: Family Matters played a significant role in providing a positive portrayal of a middle-class Black family on primetime television, breaking stereotypes and paving the way for more Black-led sitcoms.
Q5: Is Family Matters still popular today?
A: Yes, Family Matters remains a cultural staple, with reruns and streaming platforms introducing it to new audiences, keeping the legacy of the Winslow family alive.
