Every major franchise ending comes with strong emotions. After Everything (2023), the fifth film of the After series, has not only wrapped up many story threads but also stirred controversies and polarized opinions among its fan base. In this article, we explore the sources of fan backlash praise and discontent, and why After Everything became one of the most discussed entries in the franchise.
Expectation Versus Reality
Fans of the After novels expected a faithful adaptation of Anna Todd’s work. The first four films closely followed the books. After Everything, however, diverged significantly—introducing new characters, shifting character focus, and using previously filmed footage for Tessa Young’s role.
The reduction of Josephine Langford’s screen time and original scenes frustrated many. Some viewers felt that Tessa, once a co-equal protagonist, became sidelined.
New Characters and Narrative Changes
One major source of controversy is the introduction of Natalie, played by Mimi Keene, and Sebastian played by Benjamin Mascolo. These new or expanded characters take narrative weight in After Everything in ways that some fans view as altering the central dynamic of Hardin and Tessa.
The storyline focuses more on Hardin’s quest for redemption and internal change than on the romantic tension that defined the earlier films. For some this is refreshing, for others it is a departure they did not want.
Praise and Positive Reception
On the positive side, some fans appreciated that After Everything attempted to mature the story. Hartin’s journey of remorse, self-reflection, and change was considered by some more emotionally satisfying than the previous cycles of heartbreak and reconciliation.
Furthermore, some reviews and audience comments praised the scenery, production values, and efforts to give Hardin a more complex inner life. For them, the film’s emotional themes struck deeper than mere romantic angst.
Social Media Storm and Criticism
There has been a wave of criticism on social media channels, particularly around perceived mis-use of the Tessa character, contract issues, and fan service. Many fans felt that the official trailers and promotion misled them about the extent of Tessa’s presence.
The production responded in some cases, denouncing harassment and urging respectful dialogue. Despite that, the tension between creative decisions and fan expectations remains a prominent topic.
Conclusion
After Everything stands as a divisive capstone to the After film series. It tried to close the story by changing the emotional focus, adding new characters, and challenging what fans had come to expect. The result is a film that some love for its growth and maturity, and others critique for what they view as misalignment with the original novels. Regardless, the debates it has sparked about character, authorship, and fan loyalty are central to its legacy.
