Season 7 of FBI continues to deliver its trademark blend of action, tension, and character-driven drama. However, Episode 4, titled “Doubted,” diverges from the show’s typical formula. Rather than focusing on the established ensemble cast, the episode shifts its narrative weight toward the introduction of Sydney “Syd” Ortiz, portrayed by National Treasure: Edge of History star Lisette Olivera. Unfortunately, this shift fails to deliver a lasting impact, as the episode struggles with pacing, character depth, and a looming sense of irrelevance due to behind-the-scenes news.
Sydney Ortiz’s Debut: A Missed Opportunity
The central plot of “Doubted” revolves around Sydney Ortiz, a newly introduced FBI profiler whose life becomes intertwined with the case of her sister, Melanie Ortiz, who is attacked by a stranger in her apartment. Dissatisfied with the local police’s approach, Sydney persuades FBI Assistant Director Isobel Castille to intervene, unveiling a larger conspiracy in the process.
The premise sets the stage for Sydney’s addition to the team, but the execution falters. From the outset, Sydney’s introduction feels more like an obligatory narrative device than an organic addition to the show. Her character is the driving force behind the episode, leaving little room for the series’ core cast to shine. Maggie Bell, OA Zidan, and Stuart Scola—the heart of the show—are relegated to supporting roles.
Why Sydney Ortiz Falls Flat
Sydney Ortiz is built from a collection of familiar tropes:
- The overachieving rookie profiler.
- A challenging personal life with familial connections to law enforcement.
- A storied father figure who conveniently shares history with Isobel Castille.
These elements might have worked with more nuanced writing or stronger integration into the show’s dynamics, but Sydney’s portrayal lacks depth. Her professional competence as a profiler feels inconsistent with her portrayal as an overeager, somewhat naïve field agent. This dichotomy makes her feel less credible in a series where realism and teamwork are key.
Additionally, profilers are not new to the procedural genre. Shows like Criminal Minds have explored the role extensively, setting a high bar for characterization. Sydney, unfortunately, brings little innovation to the archetype, making her introduction feel redundant rather than refreshing.
The Real-Life Context: Casting Challenges
The episode’s shortcomings are exacerbated by real-world casting news. Shortly before the episode aired, it was revealed that Lisette Olivera’s character would not remain on the show. Reports cited that Olivera appeared “too young” to convincingly portray an FBI Special Agent, a sentiment echoed by viewers who struggled to connect with her performance.
This behind-the-scenes revelation casts a shadow over “Doubted.” Knowing that Sydney Ortiz’s tenure on the show is short-lived makes it difficult for audiences to invest in her character. Instead of generating intrigue, the episode feels like a narrative detour with no lasting significance.
Missed Opportunities for the Ensemble Cast
One of FBI’s strengths is its ensemble cast, whose chemistry and individual storylines anchor the show. Episodes typically balance personal character arcs with compelling cases, giving fans reasons to care about both the crimes being solved and the people solving them.
In “Doubted,” however, this balance is absent. Characters like Maggie Bell and OA Zidan are relegated to the sidelines, while Sydney’s introduction takes center stage. Even Stuart Scola, who often thrives in episodes centered on interpersonal dynamics, feels underutilized. This lack of focus on the core team creates a disjointed viewing experience, as fans tune in for the ensemble but are instead presented with an underdeveloped standalone character.
What Could Have Worked Better
Sydney Ortiz’s introduction might have succeeded with a more measured approach. Instead of dedicating an entire episode to her story, the writers could have gradually integrated her into the team over several episodes. This would have allowed audiences to warm up to her character and understand her role within the established dynamic.
Additionally, exploring a more unique angle for Sydney’s character might have helped her stand out. Instead of relying on tropes, the show could have delved into uncharted territory—such as examining the psychological toll of being a profiler or highlighting her struggles with imposter syndrome. These elements could have made Sydney more relatable and memorable.
Looking Ahead: Lessons for FBI
While “Doubted” falls short, it serves as a reminder of what makes FBI so compelling: the interplay between its established characters and the high-stakes cases they tackle together. The show thrives when it allows its ensemble to shine, using guest stars and new characters to enhance rather than overshadow the main cast.
As FBI moves forward, the focus should remain on developing its core team and introducing new characters in a way that feels natural and purposeful. With the promise of a full 22-episode season, the writers have ample opportunity to refine their approach and avoid similar missteps.
Final Thoughts
FBI Season 7, Episode 4, “Doubted,” is a well-intentioned but ultimately lackluster attempt to introduce a new character. Sydney Ortiz’s debut feels rushed and out of sync with the show’s established formula, leaving little impression on audiences. While the episode isn’t without its moments of intrigue, it fails to capture the heart of what makes FBI a standout procedural.
For long-time fans, “Doubted” may feel like a minor hiccup in an otherwise strong season. With the core team’s chemistry intact and promising storylines on the horizon, there’s every reason to believe that FBI will continue to deliver the thrilling, character-driven drama viewers have come to expect.
