A Show That Outlived Expectations
When Family Matters first aired on ABC in September 1989, no one expected it to last more than a season or two. It began as a modest spinoff of Perfect Strangers, a family-centered sitcom set in Chicago about Harriette Winslow, her police officer husband Carl, and their children. Initially, critics dismissed it as “yet another family sitcom” in an era already dominated by Full House, The Cosby Show, and Who’s the Boss?.
But something extraordinary happened. Over the next nine years, Family Matters grew from a safe, low-stakes comedy into a pop-cultural phenomenon. It became one of the longest-running American sitcoms featuring a predominantly Black cast, spanning 215 episodes and leaving behind a legacy that resonates with audiences even decades later.
The key to its survival? A nerdy kid with suspenders, high-pitched voice, and an unforgettable catchphrase: “Did I do that?”
The Origins: Building the Winslow Family
The Winslows were designed to be the heart of the series. Carl Winslow (played by Reginald VelJohnson) was a hardworking Chicago police officer; Harriette Winslow (Jo Marie Payton) was the strong-willed mother; and their household included three kids—Eddie, Laura, and little Judy—alongside Carl’s mother, Estelle, and Harriette’s sister, Rachel, plus Rachel’s young son, Richie.
Unlike many sitcoms of its era, Family Matters tried to ground its comedy in the real struggles of a middle-class Black family. The Winslows worried about finances, discipline, and community issues. For its first half-season, episodes tackled topics like gun violence, school challenges, and intergenerational conflicts. Critics appreciated the grounded tone but weren’t blown away. The show seemed destined to remain an average entry in the crowded sitcom lineup.
The Unexpected Star: Steve Urkel
Then came Steve Urkel.
Originally introduced as a one-off character in episode 12, Jaleel White’s Urkel was meant to be nothing more than Laura Winslow’s awkward, lovestruck neighbor. He was quirky, clumsy, and socially oblivious. But the studio audience erupted with laughter every time he appeared.
Producers recognized the lightning in a bottle. Soon, Urkel wasn’t just a guest—he became the centerpiece of the show. His exaggerated physical comedy, nerdy inventions, and iconic wardrobe (oversized glasses, suspenders, and high-water pants) turned him into a national sensation.
By season two, Family Matters was no longer the Winslows’ story—it was The Steve Urkel Show. Viewers tuned in weekly not just to follow the family, but to see what absurd invention or blunder Urkel would bring to the table.
The Catchphrases and Cultural Explosion
Television in the 1990s thrived on catchphrases, and Family Matters gave America one of its most memorable:
-
“Did I do that?” — usually after Urkel destroyed property or caused chaos.
-
“I’m wearing you down, baby!” — his relentless pursuit of Laura.
-
“No sweat, my pet.” — part of Urkel’s optimistic charm.
Jaleel White’s Urkel became a merchandising juggernaut. There were Urkel dolls, lunchboxes, T-shirts, even a breakfast cereal called “Urkel-Os.” He appeared on talk shows in character, performed dance crazes like “The Urkel Dance,” and essentially became the most recognizable sitcom character of the decade.
In a way, Family Matters proved how television could elevate a side character into a cultural icon. It mirrored the way Fonzie on Happy Days or Kramer on Seinfeld stole the spotlight—but Urkel was different. He wasn’t cool; he was a caricature of “the nerd,” and yet children adored him, and families found him endearing.
The Shift: From Realism to Surrealism
While early seasons balanced family drama with Urkel’s slapstick comedy, later seasons pushed the show into stranger territory.
Urkel became not only clumsy but also a genius inventor. He created transformation chambers that turned him into the suave “Stefan Urquelle,” shrinking machines, jetpacks, and even a time-travel device. Episodes began resembling science fiction more than family comedy.
This shift divided fans. Some missed the more grounded Winslow-centered stories, while others loved the over-the-top creativity. By the late 1990s, Family Matters was both praised for its uniqueness and criticized for abandoning its original heart.
Representation Matters: A Black Family on Primetime
Despite its eccentric evolution, Family Matters played an important role in representation. Alongside The Cosby Show and Fresh Prince of Bel-Air, it showcased an African American family in a positive, middle-class light at a time when few shows did.
Carl Winslow wasn’t just comic relief—he was a caring father who taught moral lessons. Harriette was strong, opinionated, and independent. Even Estelle, the grandmother, provided wisdom and heart.
For many Black families watching in the 1990s, the Winslows offered both relatability and aspiration. The sitcom helped normalize the presence of Black-led shows in mainstream television, paving the way for later series like Black-ish and Everybody Hates Chris.
Behind the Scenes: Tensions and Changes
As beloved as Family Matters was, life behind the camera wasn’t always easy. Jaleel White, though adored by fans, sometimes clashed with castmates. In later interviews, some co-stars admitted that his rise to stardom shifted the dynamics on set, with the Winslow family often pushed into the background.
There were also major cast changes: Jo Marie Payton (Harriette) left before the final season, replaced by actress Judyann Elder. Jaimee Foxworth, who played Judy Winslow, was written off entirely after season four without explanation—leading to long-running jokes about the “disappearing daughter.”
Despite these challenges, the cast remained professional, and the show held its audience for nearly a decade.
The End of an Era
By the late 1990s, ratings began to decline. Television was shifting, with edgier sitcoms (Friends, Seinfeld) dominating audiences. Family Matters, once a Friday-night staple of ABC’s “TGIF” lineup, moved to CBS for its final season but failed to recapture its magic.
The last episode aired in July 1998, concluding with Steve Urkel finally winning Laura’s love and heading into space on a NASA mission. It was a fittingly bizarre yet heartfelt sendoff.
Though it ended quietly, the legacy of Family Matters endured.
The Reboot Question: Could the Winslows Return?
In recent years, there has been renewed interest in reviving Family Matters. Actor Bryton James (who played Richie) has pitched the idea of an animated reboot with the original cast providing voices. Warner Bros., which owns the rights, has reportedly entertained the concept, though nothing is confirmed.
Meanwhile, Jaleel White has expressed hesitation. In interviews, he emphasized that Family Matters was a show tied to the 1990s, and without key cast members—some of whom have passed away—it may be impossible to recreate the same magic.
Still, nostalgia remains strong. Streaming platforms have introduced the series to new generations, and clips of Urkel continue to circulate online.
Legacy: Why Family Matters Still Matters
Thirty years later, Family Matters is remembered for more than just Urkel. It demonstrated the staying power of family-centered storytelling, even when wrapped in absurd comedy. It proved that a predominantly Black cast could dominate primetime television. And it gave America one of its most beloved sitcom characters of all time.
For some, the show is comfort TV, a reminder of childhood. For others, it represents a significant milestone in television history. And for millions who grew up repeating “Did I do that?”, it remains a cherished piece of pop culture.
Conclusion: More Than a Catchphrase
In the end, Family Matters wasn’t perfect. It could be uneven, formulaic, or downright strange. But it managed something rare: it made people laugh, cry, and care about a quirky Chicago family for nearly a decade.
The Winslows, in all their warmth and dysfunction, invited viewers into their living room week after week. And Steve Urkel—annoying, lovable, brilliant, destructive—showed us that sometimes the least expected character can change everything.
