The After franchise has taken the world by storm, and After We Collided, the second film in the series, brought fans even deeper into the complicated romance of Hardin and Tessa. But beyond the angsty love story and emotionally charged drama lies a group of actors who truly bonded during filming. While their on-screen characters might be struggling with heartbreak, betrayal, and redemption, the cast themselves found connection, laughter, and real friendship behind the scenes. One of the best ways to explore that chemistry? A lighthearted game of “Who’s Most Likely To.”
This fan-favorite party game brought out the personalities behind the roles — revealing which cast member is the biggest goofball, who’s the emotional rock of the group, and who can’t stop laughing during serious scenes. What followed was a fun, honest glimpse at the dynamics that made filming After We Collided such a memorable experience for everyone involved.
When the cast was asked who’s most likely to forget their lines, all fingers pointed — affectionately — at Dylan Sprouse. Known for his quick wit and sense of humor, Dylan admitted that he sometimes gets distracted on set, especially when trying not to laugh. While he’s undoubtedly a professional when the cameras are rolling, even he confessed to a few memory lapses mid-scene. “Sometimes I just blank,” he laughed, “usually because I’m thinking of some dumb joke.” His castmates weren’t surprised.
In contrast, Hero Fiennes Tiffin, who plays the brooding Hardin Scott, was unanimously voted the one most likely to nail a scene on the first take. Josephine Langford, who plays Tessa, remarked that Hero has a laser-sharp focus and serious approach to acting. “He just shows up, hits his mark, and gets it done. It’s honestly impressive.” His commitment and calm demeanor helped ground many intense scenes, especially those that required raw emotional delivery.
Candice King, who joined the cast as Kim Vance, was crowned the person most likely to show up late to set — but with love. “I’ve got kids,” she joked, “so if I’m only five minutes late, that’s actually on time for me.” Despite her occasional tardiness, the cast all agreed she brought a contagious energy and warmth whenever she did arrive.
Another standout for her discipline and preparedness was Josephine Langford. The entire cast voted her as most likely to memorize everyone’s lines — not just her own. “She knows my dialogue better than I do,” Dylan admitted. Josephine simply smiled and said, “I like to be ready for anything.” Her dedication to her craft and her calm presence made her the emotional anchor for many scenes, both romantic and dramatic.
Of course, things weren’t always so serious. When asked who’s most likely to break character due to laughter, the winner was Charlie Weber, who plays Christian Vance. Despite his composed on-screen persona, Charlie was often the first to lose it during emotional scenes — especially if Dylan was whispering jokes from across the room. “It’s always the quiet moments that get me,” Charlie said with a grin.
Keeping things light on set was Karimah Westbrook, who plays Karen Scott. She was named most likely to start a dance party between takes. Whether it was blasting music, encouraging group selfies, or leading impromptu TikTok routines, Karimah’s energy helped maintain a sense of fun — even on long shooting days. “She’s the party,” Candice said. “She kept us all sane.”
