The After franchise has no shortage of passionate fans, but the latest phenomenon sweeping the fandom isn’t a new trailer or a behind-the-scenes cast update. Instead, it’s a playful yet telling personality quiz that asks a deceptively simple question: Do you belong with Hardin Scott or Trevor Matthews? The quiz, inspired by After We Collided, has caught fire across fan communities, trending on social platforms and sparking thousands of spirited debates.
What makes this quiz so irresistible? For many viewers, it goes far beyond a lighthearted game. Hardin and Trevor represent two dramatically different archetypes of romance — intensity versus stability, chaos versus comfort, passion versus predictability. The two men symbolize the emotional duality at the heart of the After universe, and choosing between them has become a way for fans to express not only their preferences, but also their personalities, values, and fantasies.
Hardin Scott, portrayed by Hero Fiennes Tiffin, remains the franchise’s most polarizing figure. His brooding energy, emotional volatility, and fierce loyalty create a magnetic pull for fans who crave depth and complexity. “Hardin feels like a storm — unpredictable but thrilling,” one fan wrote on social media. The quiz taps directly into that appeal, asking participants whether they gravitate toward intensity, midnight confessions, and dramatic emotional chemistry.
Trevor Matthews, on the other hand, appeals to viewers who prefer emotional stability and intellectual connection. Played by Dylan Sprouse, Trevor is thoughtful, measured, and refreshingly calm in contrast to Hardin’s tempestuous nature. For some fans, he represents the kind of love that is dependable, grounded, and built on mutual respect. The quiz highlights those qualities through questions about conflict resolution, communication style, and what participants value most in long-term relationships.
The viral success of the quiz also reflects the enduring influence of After We Collided within the romance genre. The film helped shape a new generation of fandom culture where viewers don’t simply watch a love triangle — they actively participate in it, projecting parts of themselves into the narrative. By inviting fans to self-identify with one of two romantic paths, the quiz reignites the emotional experience of the film and allows it to thrive long after the credits rolled.
Critics note that the quiz is cleverly designed to appeal to multiple demographics. Younger fans are drawn to its simplicity and visual aesthetic, while older fans appreciate how the questions subtly mirror real-world approaches to love. “It’s fun, but it also makes you think,” one participant shared. “Are you someone who chooses intensity, or someone who chooses peace?”
As the After franchise continues to evolve — with new viewers discovering the films through streaming and longtime fans revisiting the series — the quiz serves as both nostalgia and community bonding. It has already inspired follow-up content, from fan-made analyses to compatibility breakdowns exploring what each result says about viewers’ personalities.
For now, whether fans land in Hardin’s storm or Trevor’s calm, one thing is clear: the conversation isn’t ending anytime soon. In true After fashion, the fandom remains as passionate, divided, and engaged as ever.
