“I’m Like, ‘Guys, No’”: Full House Star Reflects On Kimmy’s Family Retcon In Netflix Sequel Series

When Fuller House brought back the Tanners, fans were thrilled to revisit their favorite characters. But one surprise caught longtime viewers completely off guard: Kimmy Gibbler suddenly had a younger brother. And it wasn’t just fans who were confused—Andrea Barber, the actress behind Kimmy, was just as shocked.

In her own words, Barber said, “I’m like, ‘Guys, no.’” Let’s talk about what went down and why it still has fans scratching their heads.

Who Is Kimmy Gibbler?

Before diving into the retcon, let’s rewind a bit. Kimmy Gibbler, played by Andrea Barber, was D.J. Tanner’s quirky best friend in Full House. Known for her offbeat fashion, odd behavior, and awkward timing, Kimmy was the show’s comic wild card.

Her family life? Mostly a mystery. She was often seen avoiding home or complaining about her parents. The show hinted at siblings—including an older brother named Garth—but no one ever made an appearance. Until Fuller House, that is.

The Fuller House Twist: Enter Jimmy Gibbler

In Netflix’s Fuller House, Kimmy’s backstory got a major shake-up. Suddenly, she had a younger brother named Jimmy Gibbler, who became a love interest—and eventually husband—for Stephanie Tanner. While fans welcomed the new character, many couldn’t help but ask: Wait, Kimmy has a brother?

Even Barber wasn’t sold. In a recent podcast interview, she recalled telling the producers that fans wouldn’t let this go. Her exact reaction?

“I’m like, ‘Guys, no. The fans are going to be all over this.’”

Why Fans Were Confused

Here’s the thing—Kimmy had referenced siblings before. Back in Full House, she mentioned having an older brother named Garth and at least three sisters. But Fuller House gave her a brand-new brother that never existed in the original timeline.

It wasn’t just a minor detail. It was a full character shift that changed Kimmy’s family dynamic. And fans who grew up watching every episode noticed instantly.

Andrea Barber Predicted the Backlash

Barber wasn’t just surprised—she knew it would stir up the fan base. She pointed out that hardcore viewers take continuity seriously, and retconning a key detail like a sibling wouldn’t fly under the radar.

She even joked that she still gets messages about it, years later.

So Who Is Jimmy Gibbler?

Jimmy Gibbler, played by Adam Hagenbuch, is portrayed as a sweet, clueless, and lovable guy. He adds a layer of humor and heart to Fuller House, especially with his relationship with Stephanie. Their chemistry worked, and their storyline ended up being a fan-favorite.

But still—his origin didn’t make sense.

No Mention of Garth?

What happened to Garth, Kimmy’s original brother from Full House? He vanished from the narrative. There’s no mention of him, no explanation—just poof, gone.

Many fans expected at least a nod to the original character. Instead, Jimmy arrived with no clear backstory, and Fuller House acted like he’d always been there.

Why the Writers Made the Change

So why did the writers go this route? Apparently, they liked the sound of “Jimmy and Kimmy.” The rhyming names added a quirky, sitcom-style vibe. But in doing so, they sacrificed continuity for convenience.

To casual viewers, it worked. To loyal fans? Not so much.

Andrea Barber’s Loyalty to the Fans

What makes Barber’s reaction so relatable is her loyalty to the audience. She wasn’t being difficult—she was being protective. She knew fans had spent decades building connections to these characters, and changing their stories without explanation felt like a betrayal.

Barber explained that as an actor, she went along with it professionally—but personally, she cringed.

How Did Fans React?

Fan forums and Reddit threads lit up with questions like:

• “Where’s Garth?”

• “Did Kimmy suddenly forget she had other siblings?”

• “Was Jimmy adopted? A secret twin? What’s the deal?”

No official answers were given. So viewers were left to either embrace Jimmy—or pretend he was never there.

The Legacy of the Retcon

Even now, the Jimmy Gibbler retcon is one of the most talked-about changes in the Full House universe. It’s proof that even small details matter when you’re dealing with iconic TV families.

In a show all about heart and history, viewers want those histories to stay intact. Or at least to be acknowledged.

What Barber Thinks Now

Andrea Barber has taken it all in stride. She still loves the character of Kimmy and the experience of filming Fuller House. But when it comes to the sibling swap?

She’s still saying, “Guys, no.”

Conclusion

The Kimmy Gibbler sibling retcon might seem minor at first glance—but it hit a nerve. For a character who’s been around since the late ’80s, fans felt protective of her story. And Andrea Barber agreed.

Sometimes, sitcoms forget that their audience is paying very close attention. In this case, Barber’s instincts were spot-on: Fuller House may have gained a Jimmy, but it also gained a lot of questions—and a few groans from longtime fans.

FAQs

1. Who played Jimmy Gibbler in Fuller House?
Jimmy Gibbler was played by actor Adam Hagenbuch, introduced as Kimmy’s younger brother and Stephanie’s love interest.

2. Did Kimmy have siblings in Full House?
Yes—she mentioned having an older brother named Garth and several sisters, although none were ever shown on screen.

3. What did Andrea Barber think about the retcon?
She admitted she was against it and warned the producers that fans would notice and question the change.

4. Was Jimmy ever explained in relation to Garth?
No—Fuller House never addressed the contradiction. Jimmy was treated as if he had always been part of Kimmy’s family.

5. Do fans still care about the change?
Definitely. It’s one of the most frequently discussed continuity errors in Fuller House, especially among long-time fans.