Chicago P.D. fans are losing their minds after Jesse Lee Soffer and Tracy Spiridakos shared a sweet selfie together while in Italy. The former co-stars, who played fan-favorite couple Jay Halstead and Hailey Upton on the hit NBC drama, sparked major speculation with their latest reunion—leading many to wonder if there’s more to the story than just a friendly getaway.
A Picture Worth a Thousand Theories
The viral selfie, posted on social media, shows Soffer and Spiridakos beaming against the picturesque backdrop of Italy. While neither of them captioned the post with any cryptic hints, fans wasted no time dissecting every detail. Were they just catching up as old friends, or could this mean something more—on or off screen?
Soffer, who exited Chicago P.D. in Season 10, has remained close with his former castmates, but his public appearances with Spiridakos always seem to stir up extra excitement. The duo had undeniable chemistry as Upstead (Upton + Halstead), making their on-screen romance one of the most beloved in the One Chicago universe.
Could This Mean a Halstead Comeback?
With Chicago P.D. Season 12 underway and Spiridakos set to exit as Hailey Upton, many fans are hoping that this reunion isn’t just a coincidence. Soffer’s departure left a massive void in the series, with Halstead’s sudden exit to Bolivia leaving Upton—and the audience—heartbroken.
Now that Spiridakos is also saying goodbye to the show, fans are hoping for a proper closure to the Upstead storyline. Could this Italy meetup mean that Jesse Lee Soffer is preparing for a cameo before Upton’s farewell?
Fans React: ‘Bring Upstead Back!’
As soon as the selfie surfaced, Chicago P.D. fans flooded social media with excitement and speculation.
- “WHAT DOES THIS MEAN?!? Are they just friends, or is Upstead making a comeback?!” one fan wrote.
- “Italy?! Together?! I refuse to believe this is just a casual hangout.”
- “Jesse better be filming a goodbye scene for Hailey or I’m rioting.”
While there’s no official word on Soffer’s return to Chicago P.D., his reunion with Spiridakos has reignited hope that Halstead might come back—even if just for one final moment with Upton before she exits the series.
A Reunion Worth Celebrating
Whether or not Soffer is gearing up for a Chicago P.D. appearance, one thing is clear—his bond with Spiridakos is as strong as ever. Their friendship, both on and off screen, remains a highlight for fans who have followed their journey as Jay and Hailey.
For now, we’ll have to wait and see if this surprise Italy getaway was just a friendly catch-up or a hint at something bigger. Either way, Upstead fans are living for the moment—and hoping for a little One Chicago magic to bring Halstead back, even if just for a goodbye.
