From Underrated Talent to Awards Contender—A Career Marked by Growing Respect and Industry Praise
For nearly two decades, Justin Hartley built a career on versatility and perseverance. But it wasn’t until his breakout role in This Is Us that the industry truly began to recognize the depth of his talent. Since then, Hartley has emerged not just as a beloved actor but as a serious contender for top television honors. His journey through the world of accolades reflects a slow-burning rise to prominence—one built on character, hard work, and emotional authenticity.
Early Career: A Respected Name Without the Headlines
In the early years of his career, Hartley worked steadily in television but received little in the way of formal recognition. His role on Passions (2002–2006) and then on Smallville (2006–2011) introduced him to large, loyal fanbases, yet soap operas and superhero shows were largely ignored by major award bodies.
Still, Hartley stood out to critics and fans for his charisma and screen presence. TV Guide and Soap Opera Digest often highlighted his performances, naming him one of daytime television’s most promising young actors. His portrayal of Oliver Queen, in particular, gained him a cult following that still endures today.
A Turning Point: This Is Us Brings Acclaim and Spotlight
The arrival of This Is Us in 2016 marked the beginning of a new chapter for Hartley—not just in terms of fame, but also artistic credibility. Playing Kevin Pearson, a deeply flawed but ultimately redemptive character, Hartley brought vulnerability and nuance to a role that could have easily been written off as superficial.
The series itself became a critical darling, collecting numerous awards, including:
-
Screen Actors Guild Awards (SAG): Hartley, as part of the This Is Us ensemble, won the Outstanding Performance by an Ensemble in a Drama Series in 2018 and was nominated multiple times between 2017 and 2022. These honors placed him onstage with some of the most respected performers in television.
-
People’s Choice Awards: In 2020, Hartley was nominated for Favorite Male TV Star and Favorite Drama TV Star, reflecting the deep resonance his character had with viewers. While he did not win, his presence among nominees like Sterling K. Brown and Milo Ventimiglia proved his growing stature.
-
Critics’ Choice Television Awards: Though the award itself went to other members of the cast, Hartley was often singled out in critical commentary as a standout, particularly in the emotionally charged episodes “Number One” and “The Fifth Wheel.”
Individual Spotlight: Moments of Praise and Standout Performances
Hartley’s strongest awards buzz came in 2017 and 2018 during This Is Us Season 2, especially after his performance in the episode “Number One,” which explored Kevin’s downward spiral and long-standing emotional wounds. Critics called it “career-defining,” and many believed it deserved Emmy recognition.
Though he did not receive a personal Emmy nomination, the omission was widely discussed. Vanity Fair and The Hollywood Reporter both named him among their “Emmy snubs” of the year, and fans launched online campaigns pushing for his inclusion in future seasons.
“Kevin’s pain felt real because Justin made it real,” wrote one New York Times critic. “There’s a subtlety to his performance that awards bodies too often overlook.”
Producing and Recognition Behind the Scenes
Hartley’s move into producing has also drawn praise. As executive producer on the CBS series Tracker and upcoming HBO Max docuseries Truth Be Buried, he has begun to shape the content he stars in—earning respect not just as an actor, but as a creative force in the industry.
While Tracker is still in its early seasons, it was selected to air in the prestigious post-Super Bowl slot in 2024—an implicit nod from CBS to its faith in both the show and its star. If the series continues its strong ratings and gains narrative depth, Hartley may finally be in line for major acting nominations in the next award cycle.
Recognition From Peers and the Industry
Outside of formal awards, Hartley has also been honored by his peers. He has served as a presenter at the Golden Globes and SAG Awards and was invited to join the Television Academy’s Performers Peer Group in 2021. His acceptance into this body—composed of Emmy voters—signals increasing respect for his contributions to television.
In 2022, he was also honored with the Inspiration Award at the L.A. Family Housing Awards Gala for his philanthropic work, particularly around homelessness and veteran support programs.
“Justin has always led with heart, both on and off the screen,” said the event’s organizers. “He reminds us that real leadership in Hollywood includes service to others.”
Looking Ahead: Will the Emmys Come Calling?
As Hartley takes on more complex roles—such as the troubled senator in the upcoming political thriller Capital Veins—many believe his best shot at a personal acting award still lies ahead. The film is already rumored to be an awards contender, and with Netflix behind it, the campaign support is likely to be significant.
His layered portrayal of a man torn between moral integrity and political compromise could finally earn him the solo nomination fans have long felt he deserves.
A Career Worthy of Recognition
Justin Hartley’s awards journey has been less about flashy wins and more about steady elevation. He has gone from being underestimated to being unavoidable, with performances that linger long after the credits roll.
In an era obsessed with overnight fame, Hartley is a reminder that recognition, when it comes through craft and conviction, is worth the wait. Whether or not he holds an Emmy or Golden Globe tomorrow, his legacy as a deeply respected actor is already secured.
