Mark Harmon’s departure as Leroy Jethro Gibbs in Season 19 was controversial, but it was far from the worst character exit in NCIS history. While his farewell was emotional and well-paced, several other characters were written off in ways that left fans angry, confused, or heartbroken. Here are eight character exits that were far more frustrating than Gibbs’ departure.
1. Ziva David’s Fake-Out Death (Season 11 & 16)
Ziva’s original exit in Season 11 was already frustrating, but when NCIS later revealed that she had actually faked her death, it only made things worse. Fans had been mourning her for years, only to learn she had been alive all along. The way the show handled her “return” felt like a rushed attempt to fix past mistakes.
2. Tony DiNozzo’s Off-Screen Farewell (Season 13)
For a character as beloved as Tony, leaving NCIS without a proper farewell scene with Gibbs or Ziva felt like a betrayal. While his reason for leaving (to raise his daughter) was understandable, the execution left much to be desired.
3. Abby Sciuto’s Bitter Departure (Season 15)
Unlike Gibbs, who got a peaceful send-off, Abby’s exit was surrounded by real-life controversy. Reports of behind-the-scenes conflicts between Pauley Perrette and Mark Harmon overshadowed her farewell. Fans were devastated that Abby never got a final heartfelt goodbye with Gibbs.
4. Kate Todd’s Shocking Death (Season 2)
Kate’s unexpected death at the hands of a sniper was one of the most shocking moments in NCIS. While it was an effective twist, fans were frustrated that her story ended so abruptly. Unlike Gibbs, who got a chance to walk away on his own terms, Kate’s exit was brutal and final.
5. Jenny Shepard’s Tragic End (Season 5)
Jenny’s death in a shootout was dramatic, but it felt like an unnecessary way to write her off. Many fans believe her character arc could have had a more meaningful conclusion rather than a sudden, violent end.
6. Clayton Reeves’ Pointless Death (Season 15)
Reeves was a promising character, but instead of being developed further, he was randomly killed off in a robbery. His death felt unnecessary and left many fans angry at the writers for wasting his potential.
7. Mike Franks’ Death (Season 8)
Unlike Gibbs, who got a peaceful exit, Mike Franks was brutally killed off despite being a fan-favorite character. Given his importance to Gibbs’ backstory, many believe he deserved a more honorable farewell.
8. Jack Sloane’s Anti-Climactic Exit (Season 18)
Jack and Gibbs had undeniable chemistry, but her abrupt decision to leave for Afghanistan felt out of place. Unlike Gibbs, who got a full episode dedicated to his departure, Jack’s exit felt rushed and uninspired.
Why Gibbs’ Exit Was Actually One of the Best
While some fans weren’t happy about Gibbs leaving, his departure was handled with care. He got to make a choice, say proper goodbyes, and start a new life. Compared to these eight frustrating exits, Gibbs was given a rare gift in NCIS—a well-earned and meaningful farewell.
