Jesse Lee Soffer has captivated audiences for years with his portrayal of Jay Halstead on Chicago P.D.. His sudden departure from the show left many fans heartbroken, and now, with his new role as Special Agent Wes on FBI, the question arises—should he stay in his new world, or should he make a triumphant return to One Chicago?
Halstead was a fan favorite, known for his strong moral compass, leadership skills, and deep connection with his colleagues—especially his relationship with Hailey Upton. His exit felt abrupt, and many viewers still believe his story in Chicago P.D. remains unfinished. A return would not only bring closure but also shake up the Intelligence Unit, which has changed significantly in his absence.
On the other hand, his new role in FBI offers a fresh start. Playing Special Agent Wes allows Soffer to explore a different character within the crime procedural genre, and it gives him the opportunity to grow beyond the shadow of Halstead. FBI is another highly successful franchise, and if his character resonates with audiences, this could be a long-term move for his career.
Ultimately, the decision comes down to whether Soffer wants to continue forging a new path or revisit the character that made him a household name. While many Chicago P.D. fans are still holding out hope for his return, only time will tell if Halstead walks back into the Intelligence Unit—or if Wes becomes his next defining role.
