Simon Cowell, known for his sharp critiques on *American Idol*, once doubted Jennifer Hudson’s potential as a superstar. Nearly two decades later, Cowell reflects on his early judgments and praises Hudson for her incredible journey and accomplishments.
### **Early Days on *American Idol***
When Jennifer Hudson competed on *American Idol*, Simon Cowell was one of the show’s most formidable judges. Despite Hudson’s undeniable talent, Cowell was critical of her performances, particularly when Hudson was eliminated during Barry Manilow week. Hudson’s performance of Manilow’s “Weekend in New England” was a turning point, and Cowell later admitted that the choice of song was less than ideal, leading to Hudson’s early exit from the competition.
### **A Change of Heart**
In a full-circle moment, Cowell appeared on *The Jennifer Hudson Show* in September 2022. He expressed his admiration for Hudson’s journey since their time on *Idol*. Cowell acknowledged his earlier doubts but praised Hudson for her resilience and success.
– **On Hudson’s Journey:** “All those memories I have right from the beginning is, ‘Why was the show so big in those days?’ It was because of people like you,” Cowell told Hudson. He recognized Hudson’s determination, personality, and grace, even amid tough critiques.
– **Reflections on Elimination:** Cowell recalled Hudson’s elimination and reflected on his own regrets about the song choice. “I remember thinking, ‘This is not a great song.’ Wasn’t your fault,” Cowell said, acknowledging the role of the song choice in Hudson’s early exit.
### **Hudson’s Rise to Stardom**
Despite her *Idol* elimination, Hudson’s career flourished spectacularly. She went on to star in the film adaptation of *Dreamgirls*, earning an Academy Award for Best Supporting Actress. Her achievements have only solidified her status as a vocal and acting powerhouse.
– **Cowell’s Praise:** “Without sounding sycophantic, you are the epitome of the American Dream,” Cowell told Hudson. He admired her perseverance and success, noting that many would have given up after such setbacks.
### **Hudson’s Reflections**
When asked if she would change her final song choice on *American Idol*, Hudson revealed she has no regrets about her final performance. She appreciated how the song led to her getting the *Dreamgirls* role, noting that it was instrumental in her career trajectory.
– **Hudson’s Perspective:** “That song, do you know it led me to getting Dreamgirls, honey,” Hudson said. “Barry Manilow structured that song as if it was ‘And I Am Telling You,’ and a lot of people thought that’s what I was singing.”
### **Conclusion**
Simon Cowell’s change of heart about Jennifer Hudson underscores her remarkable journey from an *American Idol* contestant to an acclaimed EGOT winner. Cowell’s admiration for Hudson’s achievements highlights her status as a true embodiment of the American Dream.
