Season 2 of So Help Me Todd picks up right where its successful first season left off, delivering the same engaging mix of humor and drama that made the show a hit. Premiering in 2022, the series introduced Skylar Astin as Todd, a struggling private investigator who reconnects with his mother, Margaret (Marcia Gay Harden), a high-powered attorney. The chemistry between Astin and Harden was a standout feature, and Season 2 continues to leverage their dynamic effectively.
The conclusion of Season 1 saw significant changes for the characters: Margaret was named a partner at her law firm, Todd regained his investigator license, and Allison (Madeline Wise) was offered a promising retreat. However, the arrival of Margaret’s ex-husband Harry (Mark Moses), who declared “Iceland was horrible!” set the stage for more complications.
Season 2 Stays True to What Works
In Season 2, things quickly become chaotic. Harry’s return disrupts Margaret’s relationship with Gus (Jeff Nordling), Todd faces challenges in reestablishing his business, and Allison finds herself scammed. The law firm Crest, Folding, and Wright is also in financial trouble, leading to the difficult decision of firing sixteen employees. Despite the turbulence, the show’s strength lies in the balance between Todd’s chaotic energy and Margaret’s pragmatic approach.
Astin and Harden’s on-screen chemistry remains electric, making every interaction between them engaging. The season opener, featuring an intriguing murder case and a guest appearance by Lisa Rinna, reminds viewers why So Help Me Todd is a standout. The show’s smart writing and unique blend of relatability, charm, and absurdity continue to captivate.
Evolving Relationships and New Dynamics
Season 2 also explores evolving relationships. Todd, who previously lived in Allison’s garage, now has Allison crashing on his couch after her accounts were frozen. Additionally, the show shifts away from the Todd-Susan (Inga Schlingmann) will-they-won’t-they dynamic, introducing a potential new love interest, Judy (Heather Morris). Lyle (Tristen J. Winger) is also smitten with Alex (Vinessa Antoine), who has her own mysterious motives involving the firm.
Struggles with Allison’s Character
One notable issue is the handling of Allison’s character. Despite being a key figure in Season 1, she seems sidelined in the current season, with her struggles not receiving the attention they deserve. Allison’s intelligent and assertive nature from the first season appears diminished, and her interactions with Todd lack the depth they could have. This shift might reflect a broader “Middle Child Syndrome” dynamic, where Allison’s character feels less central compared to her more attention-grabbing siblings.
A Strong Addition to the Procedural Genre
Overall, So Help Me Todd Season 2 is a brilliant addition to the procedural genre. By staying true to what worked in the first season while introducing subtle changes, the show remains both comforting and delightful. It balances complex cases with a playful tone, bolstered by a talented cast and intriguing guest stars. Season 2 continues to deliver the charm and humor that made the show a success, solidifying its place as a standout series.
