When CBS’s So Help Me Todd first hit the airwaves in 2022, it didn’t take long for fans to fall in love with its quirky blend of legal drama and family dynamics. The show, starring Marcia Gay Harden and Skylar Astin, quickly became a fan favorite. However, after its debut season ended, many viewers found themselves asking the same burning question: Will there be a Season 2 of So Help Me Todd?
As we dive into the potential for a second season, we’ll examine what viewers are saying, how CBS is responding, and what the future of the show might look like. From fan polls to viewer votes, we’ll explore whether or not this legal dramedy has the staying power to warrant a renewal, and if it does, what it will take for CBS to pull the trigger.
What Are Viewers Saying About So Help Me Todd Season 2?
A Show That Connects With Fans
When So Help Me Todd premiered in 2022, many viewers were immediately drawn to the mother-son duo at the center of the story. Marcia Gay Harden’s portrayal of Margaret Wright, a no-nonsense attorney with a sharp mind and a loving heart, paired perfectly with Skylar Astin’s portrayal of Todd, a carefree private investigator with a knack for bending the rules. The chemistry between the two was undeniable, and it quickly became one of the show’s standout features.
Many fans have taken to social media, signing petitions, and sharing their thoughts on why they want So Help Me Todd to return for another season. The general consensus among viewers is that while the show may not have reached blockbuster-level ratings, it has managed to carve out a dedicated fanbase. This fanbase has been vocal about their love for the characters and the show’s ability to blend humor with serious legal drama.
Viewer Feedback – What Are the Pros?
While So Help Me Todd may not have been a ratings hit like NCIS or Blue Bloods, viewers have been overwhelmingly positive about its storytelling and characters. Here’s a look at what fans love most about the show:
- Character Dynamics: The relationship between Margaret and Todd is the heart and soul of the series. Viewers enjoy watching the two characters navigate their differences and grow closer. The family dynamic gives the show a grounded, relatable quality, which is a refreshing change from many of the more traditional legal dramas out there.
- Strong Performances: Both Marcia Gay Harden and Skylar Astin have been praised for their performances. Harden, a seasoned actress known for her roles in Pollock and Fifty Shades of Grey, brings a level of depth and nuance to the role of Margaret. Meanwhile, Astin’s Todd provides a perfect balance of humor and vulnerability. Fans have expressed their desire to see more of this dynamic in future episodes.
- Unique Genre Blend: The blend of legal drama with humor and family-oriented storytelling has set So Help Me Todd apart from other shows in its genre. Viewers have praised the show for striking a balance between tension-filled legal cases and moments of levity, making it an enjoyable watch for a wide range of audiences.
- Potential for Growth: Fans believe the show has a lot more room to grow in terms of character development and plotlines. They feel that the first season merely scratched the surface of what could be an exciting and dynamic long-term series.
Viewer Concerns – What Are the Challenges?
However, So Help Me Todd isn’t without its challenges. While there’s a loyal fanbase, not everyone is convinced that the show deserves a second season. Here are some concerns raised by viewers and critics alike:
- Viewer Ratings: Despite its positive reviews, the show’s ratings were fairly modest. For CBS, a network that’s used to massive ratings success, this may have been a red flag. If a show doesn’t pull in enough viewers, even a loyal fanbase may not be enough to justify a renewal.
- Pacing Issues: Some fans have pointed out that the pacing of So Help Me Todd felt uneven at times. While the show excelled in character moments, certain episodes seemed to drag on with overly complex cases or subplots that didn’t move the main story forward. Fans have mentioned that the show would benefit from tightening up the narrative.
- Competition from Other Shows: With so much competition in the TV landscape, including powerhouse crime and legal dramas like Law & Order and CSI, So Help Me Todd has a tough time standing out. Many viewers feel that it’s easy for CBS to prioritize more well-established franchises that already have a built-in audience.
Despite these critiques, the overall sentiment from fans seems to be one of cautious optimism. Many believe that if CBS can address some of these issues in a second season, So Help Me Todd could have the potential to develop into a bigger hit.
The Role of Viewer Votes and Petitions in Renewing So Help Me Todd
In today’s TV landscape, viewers have more power than ever before. With the rise of online petitions, fan voting campaigns, and social media buzz, networks are increasingly paying attention to what their audiences are saying. This is particularly important for shows like So Help Me Todd, which may not have had blockbuster ratings but still boast a passionate fanbase.
Petitions and Social Media Campaigns
Since the news of So Help Me Todd’s potential cancellation, fans have launched multiple online petitions urging CBS to renew the series. These petitions, which can gain thousands of signatures, are an effective way for viewers to express their desire for more episodes. Social media campaigns have also played a key role in building momentum, with fans using hashtags like #SaveSoHelpMeTodd and #RenewSoHelpMeTodd to rally support.
While petitions alone aren’t enough to secure a show’s future, they can certainly influence a network’s decision-making process. Networks like CBS want to keep their audience happy, and seeing the level of passion from fans can be a compelling reason to give a show another shot.
Viewer Votes and Ratings Impact on CBS
One of the most direct ways viewers can influence the future of a show is by participating in online voting and rating platforms. Sites like IMDb, Rotten Tomatoes, and TVLine allow viewers to rate individual episodes and overall seasons. These ratings can sometimes serve as a barometer for the network, signaling whether a show is worth keeping.
In the case of So Help Me Todd, viewer votes have been relatively positive. The show holds a respectable rating on IMDb, with fans generally giving it 7/10 or higher. While this may not be a top-tier rating, it indicates that viewers appreciate the series and are invested in its future.
Fan Expectations for a Second Season
If CBS does decide to renew So Help Me Todd, fans have certain expectations for the second season. Here are a few things viewers would like to see:
- Deeper Character Arcs: Fans want to see more development of the central characters. They hope for more backstory and emotional depth, especially when it comes to Todd’s character. Expanding on his relationship with his mother, Margaret, and his own personal struggles could add more layers to the story.
- Tighter Pacing: Many viewers have expressed that the show would benefit from a quicker pace, with more focus on the central cases and less filler material. Fans are hoping that a second season can streamline the storytelling to keep the audience hooked week after week.
- More Cases with Stakes: While So Help Me Todd did a good job of balancing humor with legal drama, fans want to see more high-stakes cases that truly challenge Margaret and Todd. More intense courtroom scenes or morally gray situations would add drama and keep viewers on the edge of their seats.
- Guest Stars and Cameos: Some fans have suggested bringing in new characters or guest stars to shake things up in the second season. Whether it’s an exciting new love interest for one of the main characters or a compelling antagonist, fresh faces could provide an interesting dynamic.
What Is CBS Saying About a Second Season?
At the time of writing, CBS has not made any official announcements about whether So Help Me Todd will return for a second season. However, the network has expressed that they are evaluating the show’s performance, including its ratings, fan feedback, and overall impact. They have acknowledged the strong fanbase but have yet to commit to a renewal.
Ultimately, whether or not So Help Me Todd returns will depend on a variety of factors, including the show’s ratings, production costs, and how well it fits into CBS’s overall programming strategy.
Conclusion: Will ‘So Help Me Todd’ Get Renewed for Season 2?
As of now, the fate of So Help Me Todd rests in the hands of CBS executives. Fans are hopeful, however, and have made their voices heard through petitions, social media campaigns, and viewer votes. While the show may not have had the highest ratings, it has certainly carved out a niche audience that continues to support it. If CBS takes into account the passionate fanbase and makes some adjustments to the pacing and storytelling, there’s a chance that So Help Me Todd could get a well-deserved second season.
For now, fans can continue to show their support by voting for the show, signing petitions, and spreading the word. With enough momentum, there’s still hope that Margaret and Todd’s story isn’t over just yet.
