CBS’s legal dramedy So Help Me Todd wrapped up its run in a way that no one saw coming—a cliffhanger that left fans stunned, frustrated, and desperate for answers. With no official renewal, the show was cut short just when things were about to get really interesting.
So, why did CBS pull the plug? What was supposed to happen next? And will we ever get closure on Margaret and Todd’s story? Let’s break it all down.
Why ‘So Help Me Todd’ Was Canceled By CBS
CBS’s Decision: Ratings vs. Potential
While So Help Me Todd gained a devoted fanbase, CBS ultimately decided not to renew it for a third season. The show’s ratings were decent but not strong enough to secure its place in an increasingly competitive lineup.
Network Shuffling and Scheduling Conflicts
CBS is constantly making room for new content, and despite So Help Me Todd’s unique blend of humor and drama, it didn’t make the final cut. The network likely prioritized shows with broader appeal or stronger advertising revenue.
The Writers’ Strike Factor
The Hollywood writers’ strike may have also played a role in the show’s fate. With delays in production, some shows were left in limbo, leading networks to make tough renewal and cancellation decisions.
Breaking Down the Cliffhanger Ending
The Mystery That Was Never Solved
The finale set up a major mystery—one that was supposed to launch into a thrilling new season. However, with the show canceled, fans were left wondering about unresolved storylines, particularly Margaret’s legal battle and Todd’s fate.
Margaret’s Career in Jeopardy
Margaret (Marcia Gay Harden) was facing a critical moment in her legal career. The finale hinted at a major case that could change everything, but we never got to see how it played out.
Todd’s Personal Struggles
Todd (Skylar Astin) was dealing with his own battles, trying to establish himself outside of his mother’s shadow. The last episode teased a significant turning point, but viewers never got to see the outcome.
What Would Have Happened in Season 2?
Margaret’s Big Courtroom Battle
Season 2 was reportedly set to feature Margaret taking on a career-defining case—one that could either cement her legacy or ruin her reputation.
Todd’s Unexpected Career Move
Todd was likely going to pivot into a new career path, possibly taking on a role that put him at odds with Margaret in the courtroom.
A New Family Rift or Reconciliation?
Would Todd and Margaret’s complicated relationship have improved, or would their differences have driven them further apart? The showrunners hinted at major changes that we’ll now never get to see.
Fan Reactions: Outrage and Disappointment
Social Media Backlash
Fans took to Twitter, Reddit, and Facebook to express their frustration with the show’s abrupt ending. Many felt robbed of closure and were vocal about wanting a proper conclusion.
Petitions for a Revival
Like many beloved but prematurely canceled series, So Help Me Todd has sparked petitions from fans hoping for a revival on another network or a streaming service.
Could ‘So Help Me Todd’ Be Saved?
A Netflix or Hulu Rescue?
With streaming services often picking up canceled shows (Manifest, Lucifer), some fans are holding out hope that So Help Me Todd could find new life elsewhere.
A Limited Series Finale?
If a full renewal isn’t possible, CBS could at least consider a two-hour finale special to wrap up the unfinished storylines.
Skylar Astin and Marcia Gay Harden’s Next Moves
Even if the show doesn’t return, the talented cast will likely move on to new projects. Fans will be watching closely to see where they go next.
Conclusion: A Frustrating Goodbye with Unanswered Questions
So Help Me Todd had the potential to grow into a long-running, fan-favorite show. Instead, it was cut short with a frustrating cliffhanger that left viewers hanging. While a revival isn’t guaranteed, the passion of the fanbase could still make a difference.
Will CBS reconsider? Could another network step in? Or will So Help Me Todd remain one of those unfinished TV stories that fans never get over?
Only time will tell.
