The Surprising End to a Beloved Show
For fans of So Help Me Todd, the two-season run was a delightful blend of crime drama and family dynamics. However, the finale on May 16 left viewers in a state of bewilderment with its unexpected cliffhanger. Created by Scott Prendergast, the show starred the immensely talented Marcia Gay Harden and Skylar Astin, who brought the unique mother-son duo to life.
But why did the series end this way? And what were the intended plans for Margaret and Todd if the show had continued? Let’s dive into the details!
Why the Cliffhanger?
The Decision to End with a Bang
When the creators pitched the story arc for Season 2, they envisioned a dramatic conclusion. “We wanted to do sort of an Empire Strikes Back-y end with a dangerous note,” Prendergast explained. The idea was to leave audiences hanging, filled with anticipation for a third season. Unfortunately, things took a turn when CBS announced the cancellation just weeks before filming wrapped.
Timing is Everything
By the time the cancellation news broke on April 19, the production team had already completed filming the finale. Prendergast noted that there were signs leading up to the cancellation, making it a bittersweet experience for everyone involved. Despite the looming uncertainty, they had aimed for an exciting cliffhanger, only to be met with disappointment from the loyal fanbase.
What Would Have Happened Next?
Margaret’s Legal Trouble
Had So Help Me Todd been granted a third season, the story would have taken a dramatic turn for Margaret. She would find herself embroiled in a series of legal troubles, accused of crimes she didn’t commit. Prendergast revealed that Margaret would get arrested and face trial, leading to Todd’s behind-the-scenes efforts to clear her name.
The Return of Old Faces
In this alternate universe, the family would band together to confront the challenges ahead. Susan, a recurring character played by Inga Schlingmann, would return to lend her support. The theme of familial loyalty and collaboration would have been central to the storyline, capturing the essence of what fans loved about the show.
Todd and His Romantic Life
Todd’s Relationship Journey
Meanwhile, Todd’s love life would also have taken some interesting twists. Initially, he and Judy (played by Heather Morris) were set to be a couple for a few more seasons. However, as the story progressed, the narrative would lead Judy to move to Thailand, leaving the door open for Todd to eventually reconnect with Susan. This would have introduced fresh dynamics and romantic tension, keeping viewers engaged.
A New Career Path
Todd would not only navigate his personal life but also evolve professionally. He was poised to take his investigative skills to the next level by opening his own private detective agency. This shift would have opened up new storylines and provided opportunities for character development and exploration.
The Future of Supporting Characters
Allison’s Aspiring Career
Allison, portrayed by Madeline Wise, was on track to become a forensic pathologist, reminiscent of the iconic Quincy Jones. The creators had even envisioned a spinoff centered around her character, further expanding the universe of So Help Me Todd.
The Chemistry That Captivated Fans
The success of the show can largely be attributed to the chemistry between Marcia Gay Harden and Skylar Astin. Prendergast likened their dynamic to the beloved pairing of Moonlighting, emphasizing that audiences were drawn to their familial love. The characters’ struggles and triumphs resonated with viewers, making the show more than just another procedural drama.
The Fan Response and Cancellation Aftermath
Unexpected Fan Reactions
The backlash from fans upon learning of the cancellation was overwhelmingly positive yet surprising to Prendergast. “I can’t go on social media anymore,” he shared, reflecting on the numerous messages he received from devoted viewers. The love for the show manifested in various petitions, with tens of thousands of signatures advocating for its return.
The Challenge of Network Television
The challenges faced by So Help Me Todd stemmed from a confluence of factors, including the ongoing writers’ strike, competition from other successful shows on CBS, and the network’s potential sale. Prendergast acknowledged that the show’s lower ratings were also a significant factor in the cancellation decision.
A Look Ahead: The Future of Broadcast TV
Moving Forward
Though So Help Me Todd has ended, Scott Prendergast remains optimistic about the future of television. He expressed gratitude for the experience and the talented team that worked alongside him. “It’s nice to have a little bit of a break,” he noted, alluding to the grueling hours spent on production.
What’s Next for Prendergast?
With the cancellation, Prendergast is ready to explore new opportunities. “On to the next opportunity,” he stated, looking ahead with hope and enthusiasm for future projects. Fans can only hope that his next endeavor captures the same heart and humor that made So Help Me Todd a beloved series.
