The Unexpected Heartthrob of Steve Urkel
If you grew up watching Family Matters, you probably assumed Laura Winslow was Urkel’s one true love. That bromance-turned-romance was the show’s central thread. But what if I told you there was another character—with just enough screen time—to genuinely win his heart? It’s a twist worthy of a Season 5 plot arc.
Why Laura Was the Obvious Choice—but Not the Only One
Laura Winslow, portrayed by Kellie Shanygne Williams, was Urkel’s most obvious romantic pursuit. They shared chemistry, comedy, and countless “Did I do that?” moments. But sometimes true love lies in the shadows, in the unscripted, overlooked moments.
Enter Myra Monkhouse: The Real Urkel Game-Changer
Who is Myra Monkhouse?
Played by Michelle Thomas, Myra was introduced midway through Season 6 as a flashy, confident, and borderline obsessively cute crush on Urkel. Unlike Laura, Myra didn’t need convincing—she saw Urkel’s awesomeness from day one.
What Made Their Chemistry Spark
Myra and Urkel clicked instantly. They shared goofy humor, unexpected charm, and high-energy presence. For a change, Urkel didn’t chase—he was chased. And that shift flipped everything.
How Myra Changed the Dynamics of Family Matters
Breaking the Unrequited Mold
Laura’s hesitation allowed urgent chase energy to drive storylines. Myra’s bold pursuit flipped that on its head and forced Urkel to confront his own feelings—giving him a taste of humility and respect.
New Storylines, Fresh Energy
With Myra around, episodes focused on mutual antics, like peanut butter circumcision jokes or her inventing a crush her cat. Drama and humor mixed with Urkel’s signature goofiness, refreshing the show’s dynamics.
Fan Reactions: Team Laura vs. Team Myra
Why Some Fans Prefer Laura
Laura feels like home. She’s gentle, nurturing, and familiar to the Winslow family. Plus, there’s nostalgia in chasing first love.
Why Others Rooted for Myra
Myra brought confidence, originality, and compatibility. She didn’t just love Urkel—she got him. Fans appreciated seeing him respected the way he respected her.
Cast Reflections on Urkel’s True Love
Michelle Thomas (Myra):
She once said in interviews that Myra and Urkel were “the perfect match,” sharing personality and energy. It wasn’t just fluff—she believed in their chemistry.
Jaleel White (Urkel):
White has commented that Myra was a turning point for Urkel’s maturity—helping him learn emotional vulnerability, balance, and respect.
Lessons from Myra and Steve’s Relationship
-
Confidence Attracts: Myra pursues, Urkel responds. Mutual attraction blossomed naturally.
-
Shared Humor Is Key: Inside jokes, playful teases, and laughter formed their emotional connection.
-
Equality Matters: Neither chased the other; they respected each other’s quirks and differences.
Could There Be a Reboot Romance?
Speculation about revivals often focuses on Laura and Urkel finally ending up together. But what if a reboot leaned into Urkel’s real compatibility with Myra? A modern version could explore realistic adult romance, relationship growth, and mutual respect.
Why the Myra‑Urkel Love Story Still Matters
It reminds us that love can be surprising—it can come from the bold, the unexpected, the “other.” It also shows that growth and mutual respect don’t always follow traditional rom-com scripts.
The Bigger Picture: Why We Root for Underdogs Like Myra
Family Matters thrived on underdog characters—Urkel, Harriette as the working mom, Carl quietly learning to open up. Myra fits that mold: not the default choice, but the foil that challenges and changes the main character.
Final Thought: Love Isn’t Always What We Expect
Laura Winslow offered comfort and familiarity. Myra offered challenge and change. And sometimes the real love story isn’t the one we’ve rehearsed—it’s the one that surprises us.
Conclusion
While Steve Urkel’s relationship with Laura boasts classic rom-com energy, it’s his dynamic with Myra Monkhouse that showcases genuine growth, respect, and connection. Myra pushed him, supported him, and cherished him—just as he deserves. And that’s why, deep down, Urkel’s true heart belonged to her.
5 Unique FAQs
1. Was Myra Monkhouse always meant to be Urkel’s love interest?
Not necessarily. Her character emerged from writers wanting to shake things up, and chemistry proved it was the right move.
2. Did fans prefer Urkel & Myra over Urkel & Laura?
It split fans. Some stuck with romance nostalgia (Team Laura); others championed maturity and mutual respect (Team Myra).
3. Did Jaleel White enjoy working with Michelle Thomas?
Yes—both actors noted their chemistry on camera and mutual respect off camera.
4. Were there ever hints of Urkel-Lorla and Urkel-Myra fights in fandom?
Online forums often debated it, with passionate fans on both sides defending their pairings.
5. Could a reboot reignite Urkel & Myra’s storyline?
Absolutely. A modern reboot could explore their adult reunion—respect- and humor-grounded relationship that evolves naturally.
