A Surprising Shift in the Cast
As Tracker prepares for its highly anticipated Season 3, many fans are still reeling from the news that two of the show’s most compelling supporting actors — Abby McEnany and Robin Weigert — will not be returning. These two actresses, known respectively for their portrayals of quirky informant Velma (McEnany) and steadfast bounty-hunter Dory (Weigert), played crucial roles in shaping the emotional landscape and narrative texture of Tracker’s first two seasons.
Their absence leaves a noticeable void not just in character dynamics, but in the heart of the storytelling itself. With both characters gone, Season 3 will have to recalibrate its tone, emotional depth, and relationship structures — and fans are already speculating about whether the show can maintain its unique identity without them.
Robin Weigert as Dory: The Quiet Backbone
Robin Weigert’s portrayal of Dory stood out as one of the most grounded and emotionally intelligent performances on the show. As a fellow tracker who occasionally partnered with Colter Shaw (played by Justin Hartley), Dory provided a moral compass and a counterbalance to Colter’s solitary instincts. Her experience, patience, and guarded warmth added a layer of maturity to the often fast-paced episodic structure of Tracker.
Weigert’s exit reportedly stemmed from a mix of creative direction changes and scheduling conflicts. However, her departure represents more than just the loss of a supporting character — it’s the departure of a quiet emotional pillar in Colter’s world.
Abby McEnany as Velma: The Unfiltered Truth-Teller
Velma, played by Abby McEnany, offered an offbeat charm and intelligence that became a fan favorite. As an information broker with a no-nonsense attitude, Velma’s scenes often injected moments of levity and sardonic humor into otherwise tense narratives. Her chemistry with Colter was unique — a mix of mutual respect, friction, and unspoken care.
McEnany’s role, though often limited to short appearances, left an outsized impression. The decision to remove her character from Season 3 — reportedly due to a new creative focus on serialized storytelling — has disappointed viewers who appreciated the show’s tonal variety and rich side characters.
What Their Absence Means for Season 3
Season 3 will mark a clear tonal pivot. With the loss of Velma and Dory, the new season appears to be leaning more into high-stakes mystery arcs and emotional isolation, focusing heavily on Colter’s internal struggle and backstory. While this may offer a deeper dive into Justin Hartley’s character, it also risks narrowing the emotional range of the show.
Without Dory’s mature grounding or Velma’s sharp wit, Colter could become even more of a lone wolf — for better or worse. The dynamic ensemble cast once offered a world in which Colter’s beliefs and behavior were constantly challenged or balanced. Now, with fewer returning characters, those contrasts might disappear.
Could They Still Return?
Fans remain hopeful for guest appearances. Both actresses have left the door open in interviews for possible cameos, depending on storylines and schedules. With the serialized format allowing flashbacks or parallel arcs, it’s not out of the question that we could see one — or both — characters make a brief return.
Still, showrunners have emphasized that Season 3 is intended as a “narrative reset,” focusing more on a contained mystery that stretches across multiple episodes rather than episodic quests. That might reduce the chances of unexpected reunions — at least for now.
A New Direction, But at What Cost?
It’s always a gamble when a show dramatically reshapes its cast and tone. Sometimes, the changes breathe fresh life into a series. Other times, they strip away what made it special. In the case of Tracker, the loss of Abby McEnany and Robin Weigert leaves behind questions not just about plot, but about emotional resonance.
Can Tracker continue to thrive without two of its most nuanced and fan-loved characters? Season 3 will have to work harder to earn the same level of investment — because without Velma and Dory, the path ahead feels lonelier than ever.
