For many fans of The Summer I Turned Pretty, Conrad seeing Belly wear the infinity necklace in Paris felt like fate stepping in at just the right moment. It was quiet, emotional, and loaded with meaning. To Conrad, that necklace said everything he had never dared to ask out loud. She brought it with her. She still cared. She still chose him. But what if that moment was never intentional at all?
What viewers are now realizing has sent shockwaves through the fandom. Belly did not consciously pack the necklace for Paris. She didn’t tuck it into her suitcase as a symbol of lingering love. It was hidden under Junior Mint’s scarf the entire time. Pure coincidence. Accidental timing. A romantic illusion that Conrad unknowingly read as a sign.
That realization completely reframes the Paris scene. Conrad’s visible surprise when he saw the necklace wasn’t just relief or joy. It was hope flooding back in. After seasons of miscommunication, restraint, and emotional distance, that small silver necklace became proof that Belly still carried him with her across the world. Or so he believed.
For Belly, the moment is softer and more complicated. She wears the necklace without fully processing how it got there or what it might mean to Conrad. To her, it may feel nostalgic, comforting, familiar. To him, it feels deliberate. And that gap between intention and interpretation is where the heartbreak lives.
Fans are now asking the painful question. If Conrad ever finds out the truth, how crushed would he be? That the symbol he thought represented choice and longing was actually just a hidden object rediscovered by chance. That the moment he treasured as quiet confirmation might not have been a message at all.
This is what The Summer I Turned Pretty does best. It builds epic romance out of silence, glances, and misunderstandings. The necklace twist isn’t just about jewelry. It’s about how Conrad and Belly have always loved each other slightly out of sync. One feeling deeply. The other unaware of how loudly their actions speak.
In a story filled with grand gestures and emotional confessions, this accidental moment may be one of the most devastating of all. Because sometimes the most romantic scenes hurt the most when you realize they were built on coincidence, not choice.
And that possibility alone is enough to make fans’ hearts ache all over again.
