When you think of Family Matters, one image instantly comes to mind — Steve Urkel, the nerdy genius, chasing after Laura Winslow with his high-pitched voice and endless devotion. For years, their love story defined the series. But what if we told you Laura Winslow wasn’t truly the love of Steve Urkel’s life?
Surprised? You’re not alone. Beneath all those “Did I do that?” moments and awkward date rejections, there was another woman who captured Steve’s heart — someone who truly loved him for who he was, suspenders and all. Let’s unravel the truth about Steve Urkel’s real love story — and the character who proved that sometimes, love isn’t about who you chase, but who sees you for who you really are.
The Enduring Love Story of Steve and Laura
Steve Urkel’s obsession with Laura Winslow was one of TV’s most iconic (and frustrating) love stories. From season one, he made his feelings crystal clear — poems, inventions, and even cloning himself just to win her heart.
Laura, on the other hand, often found Steve annoying and overbearing. Yet, as the show progressed, their relationship evolved. By the later seasons, Laura began to see the kind-hearted, intelligent man behind the suspenders. Eventually, the two ended up together — but was Laura really the one Steve should have been with?
Enter Myra Monkhouse — The Woman Who Truly Loved Steve
Here’s the twist most fans forget: Steve Urkel already had the perfect woman. Her name was Myra Monkhouse, played beautifully by the late Michelle Thomas.
Myra wasn’t just another side character; she was introduced as Laura’s friend who quickly fell for Steve. Unlike Laura, Myra didn’t laugh at Steve’s quirks — she adored them. She loved his awkwardness, his intelligence, and his big heart.
In short, Myra was everything Steve had been looking for all along — and everything Laura took years to appreciate.
Why Myra Was the Perfect Match for Steve Urkel
1. She Accepted Him Unconditionally
While Laura often tried to “fix” Steve, Myra loved him exactly as he was. She didn’t wish for him to change or tone down his personality. Myra celebrated his uniqueness. That kind of acceptance is rare — and it’s what makes Myra stand out as Steve’s true soulmate.
2. She Matched His Passion
Steve’s love for science, invention, and all things geeky wasn’t something everyone could relate to. But Myra? She dove right into it. Whether it was watching him experiment or cheering him on, she was always in his corner.
3. She Saw His Worth Before Anyone Else Did
Long before Laura’s change of heart, Myra already knew Steve was special. She saw his brilliance, his loyalty, and his compassion — things Laura ignored for years.
The Tragic Side of Myra’s Love Story
Despite Myra’s devotion, Steve eventually drifted back to Laura. The show portrayed Myra as increasingly obsessive, almost desperate, in later seasons — a character shift that many fans found unfair.
But behind the scenes, tragedy struck. Actress Michelle Thomas was battling cancer during her time on Family Matters. Her illness eventually took her life in 1998 at the young age of 30. Her passing added a real-world sadness to an already heartbreaking on-screen love story.
Why Laura Winslow Was Never the Right Fit
Let’s be honest — Laura Winslow may have been Steve’s dream girl, but she was never truly his girl.
1. She Rejected Him for Years
From the start, Laura treated Steve more like a burden than a friend. Even as he proved himself time and again, her feelings only changed when Stefan Urquelle — Steve’s cool alter ego — entered the picture.
2. She Fell for the “Cool Version” of Steve
When Steve invented the transformation chamber that turned him into Stefan, Laura instantly fell for the suave, confident version of him. But that wasn’t the real Steve — it was an illusion. Myra, on the other hand, loved both versions equally.
3. She Never Matched His Emotional Depth
Steve’s love was deep, loyal, and selfless. Laura’s affection, though genuine by the end, never carried the same emotional weight. She loved him after he proved himself, not before.
The Writers’ Decision: Why Laura “Had” to Be the One
So, if Myra was clearly Steve’s soulmate, why didn’t Family Matters let them end up together? The answer lies in television storytelling.
Laura Winslow was part of the show’s original family core. Having Steve end up with someone outside that circle might’ve felt like a detour from the show’s main storyline. The writers wanted to deliver a “happy ending” that tied everything together — even if it meant ignoring the emotional truth fans could see.
Fans Still Debate Steve’s True Love Today
Even decades later, fans still debate this storyline online. Forums, YouTube discussions, and Reddit threads are filled with passionate arguments. Team Laura vs. Team Myra isn’t just a debate — it’s a reflection of what people believe love really is.
Was it persistence that won Laura over? Or did Steve make a mistake walking away from someone who loved him without conditions?
Steve Urkel’s Character Growth Through Love
Regardless of who you think was his true love, Steve Urkel’s journey was about growth. His relationships with both Laura and Myra shaped him — teaching him about rejection, acceptance, and self-worth.
In many ways, Family Matters used Steve’s love life to explore something bigger: how love isn’t about changing to be liked, but staying true to who you are.
The Real-Life Bond Between Jaleel White and Michelle Thomas
Off-screen, Jaleel White (Steve Urkel) and Michelle Thomas (Myra Monkhouse) shared a genuine friendship. Jaleel has spoken lovingly about Michelle, calling her “the kindest soul” and revealing that her passing deeply affected him.
He even wrote a heartfelt tribute years later, saying that she was “one of the most beautiful spirits to ever grace this earth.” Their bond was real — and fans felt that chemistry on screen.
The Heartbreaking “What If”
Imagine this alternate ending: Steve realizes Laura was never his true love. He turns back to Myra, ready to give her the love she always gave him — only to find that time had run out.
It’s bittersweet, but that’s what makes Steve and Myra’s love story so powerful. It reminds us that sometimes, the one who loves you the most isn’t the one you end up with — and that’s one of life’s toughest lessons.
What Made Their Relationship So Relatable
Many fans connected to Steve and Myra’s relationship because it mirrored real life. Who hasn’t loved someone who didn’t love them back? And who hasn’t been overlooked while loving someone wholeheartedly?
Their story showed both sides — the pain of unrequited love and the beauty of being seen for who you are.
Lessons from Steve and Myra’s Story
-
Love doesn’t require perfection. Myra loved Steve for his flaws, not in spite of them.
-
Timing matters. Sometimes we realize who truly loves us only when it’s too late.
-
Be yourself. The right person won’t want to change you — they’ll celebrate you.
Why Fans Still Love Myra Monkhouse
Even years after her character’s last appearance, fans continue to celebrate Myra Monkhouse. She represented pure, unconditional love — something timeless and universal.
Her story also gave Family Matters a depth beyond its sitcom roots. She wasn’t just a love interest — she was a reminder that real love means seeing someone’s soul, not their image.
Conclusion
While Family Matters ended with Steve Urkel and Laura Winslow finally together, true fans know that the real love of Steve’s life was Myra Monkhouse. She saw his heart long before anyone else did. She embraced his weirdness, cheered for his dreams, and adored every quirky part of him.
In the end, Laura may have been Steve’s “dream girl,” but Myra was his real love story. And that’s what makes her legacy — and Michelle Thomas’s performance — unforgettable.
FAQs
1. Who was the real love of Steve Urkel’s life?
Myra Monkhouse, played by Michelle Thomas, was Steve’s true love — she loved him unconditionally.
2. Did Steve Urkel ever marry Laura Winslow?
In the series finale, Steve and Laura got engaged, suggesting they would eventually marry.
3. What happened to the actress who played Myra Monkhouse?
Michelle Thomas passed away in 1998 from cancer at just 30 years old.
4. Why did the writers choose Laura over Myra?
Writers wanted to tie the show’s main family arc together by having Steve end up with Laura Winslow.
5. Do fans prefer Myra or Laura?
Many fans today still say Myra was Steve’s true soulmate because she loved him exactly as he was.
