From the first episode, The Good Doctor introduced us to a young man who doesn’t fit the mold. Shaun Murphy—a surgical resident with autism and savant syndrome—is thrown into the chaotic world of modern medicine. His logic is flawless. His skills are brilliant. But his bedside manner? Often questioned. His emotional expression? Frequently misunderstood.
And so we ask: Is Shaun truly the “Good Doctor” the title refers to?
Or is the meaning more layered—perhaps even pointing beyond him?
Let’s explore.
To unpack the question, we first need to ask: what do we mean by “good”? Is it someone who saves lives? Who follows rules? Who makes patients feel safe? Or is it someone who dares to challenge the system for the sake of what’s right?
In The Good Doctor, we meet many characters who fit parts of that description. Dr. Glassman, who risks his career to support Shaun. Dr. Lim, who leads with compassion and strength. Even Dr. Andrews and Dr. Reznick, for all their flaws, have moments of striking integrity and growth
Shaun is undeniably talented. He diagnoses rare conditions, sees patterns no one else can, and makes bold medical decisions under pressure. But being a “good doctor” isn’t just about technical skill. Shaun often struggles with emotional nuance, empathy, and communication. His directness can alienate patients. His discomfort with touch and eye contact challenges typical expectations. And yet, there’s something deeply moral and pure about the way he approaches medicine.
He wants to help. He fights for his patients, even when others give up. He is brutally honest, not because it’s easy—but because he believes patients deserve the truth. In this way, Shaun redefines what it means to care. Maybe “good” doesn’t have to look soft. Maybe it can look like someone who shows up every day, even when the world tells them they don’t belong.
While Shaun is the protagonist, The Good Doctor gives us a rich cast of physicians who also live by the oath to “do no harm.”
-
Dr. Glassman is the emotional backbone of the series. He’s not just a mentor to Shaun—he’s a father figure who believes in second chances. When others doubt Shaun’s potential, Glassman fights for it, even at great personal cost.
-
Dr. Audrey Lim, a trauma surgeon and former Chief of Surgery, balances strength with vulnerability. Her leadership isn’t perfect, but her commitment to justice and her team is unwavering.
-
Claire Browne, though no longer on the show, stood out for her emotional intelligence. She treated patients not just with medicine but with genuine humanity.
Each of these doctors shows that being “good” isn’t about being flawless—it’s about trying, growing, and putting others before yourself. What makes the show so compelling is that the title The Good Doctor isn’t a fixed label—it’s a question. Each episode asks us to reconsider our definition of “good.” Is it about outcomes or intentions? Is it about saving the most lives—or saving one life the right way? Is it about being liked—or being right?
Shaun is not a saint. He’s socially awkward, emotionally blunt, and often frustrating. But he cares. He evolves. He listens, eventually. And he wants to do the right thing—even if it takes time to figure out what that is. We live in a world that often values charisma over character, and appearance over authenticity. The Good Doctor challenges that.
It tells us that goodness isn’t always loud or polished. Sometimes, it’s messy. Sometimes, it stutters. Sometimes, it fails—and tries again. Whether you see Shaun Murphy as the “real” good doctor or not, his story forces us to look inward and ask: What kind of people do we trust with our lives? And how do we define goodness in a system designed around perfection?
