Why ABC Pulled the Plug on The Good Doctor Despite Freddie Highmore’s Willingness to Stay

After seven heartfelt seasons, The Good Doctor came to an emotional close in 2024 — a decision that left many fans wondering why ABC chose to end one of its most beloved medical dramas while its leading star, Freddie Highmore, was reportedly open to continuing. The show’s cancellation wasn’t due to waning interest or creative exhaustion, but rather a shift behind the scenes that revealed just how delicate the balance of television production can be.

According to multiple industry insiders, ABC decided not to move forward with another season largely because of contract negotiations. Many key members of the creative team and cast had reached the end of their contracts after Season 7, and the network reportedly opted not to renew. While Highmore, who has played Dr. Shaun Murphy since the show’s debut in 2017, was willing to continue, executives felt it was the “right time to conclude Shaun’s story on a high note.”

The decision marks the end of an era for ABC, which relied on The Good Doctor as one of its strongest performers in the 10 p.m. Monday slot. The series consistently drew strong ratings and maintained a passionate global fanbase. Viewers were drawn to the character of Shaun — a brilliant young surgeon with autism and savant syndrome — whose struggles and triumphs resonated far beyond the walls of San Jose St. Bonaventure Hospital.

Insiders say that while ABC admired the show’s success, the rising costs of production and the expiration of several major contracts made renewal less feasible. The network also faced increasing pressure to make room for new projects in its post-pandemic lineup, including reboots, limited series, and streaming collaborations. Simply put, The Good Doctor had run its course in the network’s broader strategy.

Freddie Highmore expressed both pride and sadness in saying goodbye to Shaun. In a heartfelt statement, he thanked fans and the crew for their dedication, calling the experience “the most rewarding journey” of his career. He also credited the writers and producers for handling Shaun’s neurodivergence with care and authenticity — a portrayal that broke barriers in mainstream television.

As the cast shared behind-the-scenes photos and farewell messages online, the sentiment was clear: The Good Doctor wasn’t just a show; it was a symbol of empathy, resilience, and acceptance.

Looking ahead, Highmore isn’t stepping away from the screen. The British actor is now preparing for his next project, The Assassin, a Prime Video limited series set for 2025 that blends espionage with psychological drama. While fans will miss Shaun Murphy’s quiet brilliance in the operating room, they can take comfort in knowing that Freddie Highmore’s next chapter is just beginning.

For now, The Good Doctor ends not with failure, but with fulfillment — proof that even when a story closes, its impact continues to heal long after the credits roll.

Rate this post