Why did Colin Bridgerton eye Sophie Beckett during the masquerade ball if Penelope was always the one? Let’s unravel the Bridgerton mystery!
In a world where a single look can cause a scandal, we must discuss a rather curious moment that has left the ton whispering. A glittering masquerade, a silver-clad mystery lady, and two Bridgerton brothers practically tripping to win her attention. Now, considering that both Anthony and Colin are married in Netflix’s Bridgerton, who might be the two brothers, and where is this moment from?
While one is certainly the eligible bachelor Benedict Bridgerton, the other one turned out to be the ever-charming Colin—sweet Penelope’s beau, and the father of her child. But hold on, if he’s married to Penelope then why did he seem a little too intrigued by Miss Sophie Beckett? Yes, we’re talking about the upcoming character from Bridgerton Season 4. Are you already confused? Allow us to uncover the truth behind that dangerously dreamy look Colin gave Sophie.
Sophie Beckett left the two Bridgerton brothers intrigued by her grace
Before you drop the teacup, let us inform you that the above-mentioned scene is from Julia Quinn’s 2001 novel An Offer from a Gentleman—Benedict’s Story, which is yet to be adapted by the Netflix series for Season 4.
This novel not only focuses on Benedict Bridgerton’s love life and his encounter with Sophie Beckett but also unravels the story of Beckett’s life and how she went from having a Cinderella-like arc to being one of the Bridgerton wives. Now, the scene in question is from years after the death of Sophie’s father, when the ton practically lit up over one of the “events of the season”—the Bridgerton Masquerade ball.
Surprisingly, even though Sophie was treated like a lady’s maid, and was kept away from such prestigious events (not to mention that even she was disinterested in such lavish lifestyles), this time she was persuaded by the other housemaids to partake in the Masquerade ball. So, after Sophie’s stepmother and her sisters left for the party, the servants dressed her up in clothes from the attic.
Eventually, despite her initial reluctance, Sophie felt like she could definitely enjoy this one night of fun. And just like that Sophie Beckett joined the Masquerade ball, draped in a silver dream that felt straight out of a fairytale. No one knew who she was, but everyone wanted to find out. Benedict Bridgerton, the artsy heartthrob of the family was instantly drawn to her—after all, she didn’t act like a regular debutante.
But turns out, Benedict wasn’t the only Bridgerton feeling the butterflies. Even his charming younger brother, Colin, who’s known for his smooth words and curious heart, was also drawn to Sophie. When he stumbled upon her and Benedict on the terrace, he was immediately intrigued. And that’s how, from exchanging looks to enchanting both Bridgerton brothers, Sophie Beckett became the unintentional star of the evening.
Analyzing why Colin was intrigued by Sophie, despite marrying Penelope
Now, if you’re already freaking out over Colin’s flamboyant behavior towards Sophie Beckett and thinking “what about Penelope??”—take a deep breath. Turns out, Netflix truly messed up the timeline from Julia Quinn’s novels, while adapting them into the popular show, Bridgerton. Because the scene in question is from the 2001 novel, wherein, Colin was yet to fall for Penelope or even marry her.
During the Bridgerton Masquerade ball, when Sophie entered the story, Colin didn’t yet have eyes for Penelope Featherington. In fact, Benedict and Sophie’s love story happens long before Colin and Penelope’s even begins. So that look Colin gave Sophie? Totally fair game at the time. No cheating, no drama—just a young man being dazzled by a lady in silver before he met his true match.
Basically, much like Colin’s brief romantic affair with Marina Thompson—during the Masquerade ball, he was having a mini crush on Sophie Beckett. So turns out, he wasn’t in love with Sophie, he was just intrigued by her. And who wouldn’t be? Sophie had Cinderella energy, mysterious charm, and a sense of adventure that was hard to ignore. So, while it was a spark that fizzled out quickly, it made for juicy speculation.
