Let’s be real: Allison is one of the most underused characters in So Help Me Todd. And that’s saying a lot in a show full of quirky, complex characters. Despite being part of a high-achieving, dysfunctional family, Allison seems stuck in a repetitive, uninspired loop—and viewers have started to notice.
It’s time to dig into why Allison needs a serious upgrade and how the writers can revamp her arc to keep fans hooked.
Who Is Allison in ‘So Help Me Todd’?
Allison is the older sister of Todd, the title character, and a successful ER doctor. She’s sharp, composed, and logical—a perfect foil to Todd’s chaotic charm.
But here’s the issue: Allison’s character rarely gets the spotlight. Instead, she’s often reduced to the “responsible sibling” trope. That’s lazy writing in a show that otherwise prides itself on fresh character dynamics.
The Stereotype Trap—And Why It’s So Damaging
The “Perfect Sister” Cliché
Allison has become the go-to voice of reason, always fixing others’ problems while never having her own explored deeply. That’s the “perfect sister” cliché in full effect.
Lack of Character Evolution
Think about it: has Allison truly grown since Season 1? No major character development, no life-altering choices, no real risks. Just the same stoic, composed woman juggling her career and chaotic family.
Why Fans Are Losing Interest in Allison
Flat Storylines Are Killing Viewer Interest
Fans crave depth, relatability, and conflict. Allison’s plotlines often feel like filler—brief check-ins rather than engaging arcs. If viewers don’t care what happens to a character, they’ll mentally check out.
Social Media Backlash Is Growing
A quick dive into fan forums or Twitter reveals the frustration: “Why is Allison even there?” or “Give her something to do besides being the naggy sister.”
This growing criticism isn’t just noise—it’s feedback the writers need to pay attention to.
What the Show Is Doing Wrong
No Emotional Stakes
Allison’s storylines don’t carry emotional weight. We rarely see her vulnerability, internal conflicts, or personal ambitions.
Missed Romantic Opportunities
Let’s not pretend romance isn’t a big driver in character arcs. Allison has zero chemistry-driven moments or love interests that evolve. Why not explore her romantic life a bit more?
How Allison Can Be Reimagined
Now comes the good part: revamping Allison. Here’s how the show can breathe new life into her story.
Introduce an Unexpected Career Pivot
What if Allison, burned out from her ER job, explored a totally different field? Maybe she opens a wellness clinic or even takes a legal route to work with her mother and Todd. This kind of shift adds layers and gives her more reason to be present in the main storylines.
Develop a Rich Romantic Arc
A new love interest—possibly a morally gray character—could shake things up. Imagine a detective who operates in legal gray zones, challenging Allison’s rigid ethics. Boom, instant drama.
Let Her Mess Up—Big Time
Perfect characters are boring. Let Allison make a huge mistake—professionally or personally—and let us watch her rebuild. That’s how you write compelling television.
How This Would Affect the Series Overall
More Balanced Ensemble Storytelling
Giving Allison a central arc takes pressure off Todd and Margaret (their mother) and creates a stronger, more cohesive ensemble cast.
Richer Emotional Payoff
If Allison becomes more relatable, her interactions with Todd and Margaret would be far more layered and authentic. It turns a family sitcom-drama into a true character study.
What Other Shows Did Right (And ‘So Help Me Todd’ Can Learn From)
Think Alexis Rose in Schitt’s Creek
Alexis started as a shallow, selfish character and ended up being one of the most emotionally rich and beloved. Her arc was bold and vulnerable—exactly what Allison needs.
Or Look at April Kepner in Grey’s Anatomy
Another rule-follower, April became more relatable through a crisis of faith, romance, and career stumbles. Allison could benefit from the same treatment.
It’s Not Too Late—But the Clock’s Ticking
We’re not saying dump the whole show and start over. But the writers need to understand: Allison is a sleeping giant. Done right, her story could become the emotional core of So Help Me Todd.
Fans are ready for a shake-up. The question is, are the writers?
Conclusion: Time for a Bold Move
‘So Help Me Todd’ has tons of potential. The family dynamics, the legal cases, the humor—it all works. But if Allison keeps getting sidelined, the show risks losing complexity and heart.
She deserves more than background scenery. She deserves chaos, love, conflict, growth—the works.
So come on, writers. Help Allison find her voice. She’s earned it.
